City Commission Packet 06-10-2003

View the PDF version Google Docs PDF Viewer

             CITY OF MUSKEGON
             CITY COMMISSION MEETING
                    JUNE 10, 2003
         CITY COMMISSION CHAMBERS@ 5:30 P.M.


                                      AGENDA
ROLL CALL:
INTRODUCTIONS:
CONSENT AGENDA:
                a. Approval of Minutes. CITY CLERK
                b. Amendment to Non-Union Salary Schedule. FINANCE
                c. Request to Purchase Tax-Reverted Properties.           PLANNING &
                   ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
                d. Sale of Non-Buildable Lot at 330 Mason Avenue.         PLANNING &
                   ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
                e. Split and Sale of Buildable Lot at 520 E. Isabella Avenue.
                   PLANNING & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
                f.   Annual Carriage License Renewal - Muskegon Carriage Co. CITY
                     CLERK
                g. Taxicab License Renewal - Port City Cab Company. CITY CLERK
                h. Appointment to Various Boards and Committees. CITY CLERK
                i.   Consideration of Bids - Alpha Street. Commerce to Jefferson.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS:
                a. SECOND READING: Rezoning Request for Various Properties to the
                   'MC' Medical Care Zoning District. PLANNING & ECONOMIC
NEW BUSINESS:
                a. Fireworks Display - Muskegon Summer Celebration. CITY CLERK
                b. Purchase of Garbage Carts (Revised Pricing). PUBLIC WORKS
                c. Consideration of Bids - Nims & Irwin. Getty to Wood. ENGINEERING
                d. City Manager's Employment Agreement
                Joe:/~-- ~ ""1 ~
Date:    June 10, 2003
To:      Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:    Gail A. Kundinger, City Clerk
RE:      Approval of Minutes




SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To approve the minutes of the Regular
Commission Meeting that was held on Tuesday, May 27, 2003.



FINANCIAL IMPACT: None.



BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.



STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the minutes.
                CITY OF MUSKEGON
                 CITY COMMISSION MEETING
                              JUNE 10, 2003
           CITY COMMISSION               CHAMBERS@             5:30    P.M.


                                      MINUTES

   The Regular Commission Meeting of the City of Muskegon was held at City Hall, 933
Terrace Street, Muskegon, Michigan at 5:30pm, Tuesday, June 10, 2003.
   Mayor Warmington opened the meeting with a prayer from Father Michael Olson of Our
Lady of Grace Parish, after which members of the City Commission and members of the
public joined in reciting the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
ROLL CALL FOR THE REGULAR COMMISSION MEETING:
Present: Mayor Stephen Warmington, Vice Mayor Karen Buie; Commissioners Stephen
Gawron, William Larson, Robert Schweifler, Clara Shepherd and Lawrence Spataro; City
Manager Bryon Mazade, City Attorney John Schrier and City Clerk Gail Kundinger.
INTRODUCTIONS:
    Mayor Warmington introduced Ken James from Affirmative Action who introduce the
Julia Hackley Fund 2003 interns working at the City for the summer.
2003-47 CONSENT AGENDA:
                a. Approval of Minutes. CITY CLERK
   SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To approve the minutes of the Regular Commission Meeting that
   was held on Tuesday, May 27, 2003.
   FINANCIAL IMPACT: None
   BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
   STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the minutes.
                b. Amendment to Non-Union Salary Schedule. FINANCE
   SUMMARY OF REQUEST: One component of the recent contract settlement with the
   Clerical-Technical Union is the realignment of two positions (Network Technician and
   Computer Technician) to non-union status. The nearest salary ranges on the current
   non-union salary schedule are either too high or too low to accommodate these
   positions. Accordingly, staff recommends creation of a new range VII-B to meet this
   need. In line with the recent contract settlement, this change is recommended to be
   retroactive to January 1, 2003.
   FINANCIAL IMPACT: Because of the nature of the work and the access to data, staff
   believes it is appropriate and cost-effective for these positions to be non-union. The
   direct financial impact of this change is minor. The 2003 non-union salary range will be
   from $35,019 to $46,695; had the positions remained in the union, the salary range for
   2003 would have been $34,781 to $46,376.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the proposed amendment to the City's Non-Union
Salary Schedule.
             c. Request to Purchase Tax-Reverted            Properties.      PLANNING    Et
                ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Prior to 2002, the City was offered many State-owned vacant
parcels for purchase for the price of $300 for the first 5 lots and $20 per lot thereafter.
In fact, we recently submitted a request for 36 lots to the State in March 2003. Shortly
after that request was submitted, the State or Michigan sent us a large list of available
properties and asked if we wished to purchase any of them. Most of the lots that we
requested in March were on this list, however there are additional properties available.
The following list is only the new properties requested. After a call to the State, we
were informed that we could incorporate the two lists and make one request to
purchase properties. One property, #51, which was inadvertently omitted, was added
to this list since the LRC recommended approval.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: To approve the Request and to authorize the Mayor and Clerk
to sign the resolution.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: Total cost of these new properties is $1,060, in addition to the $920
already approved for the previous 36 lots.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: Expend the additional $1,060 necessary to purchase these
parcels.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: The Land Reutilization Committee recommended
approval at their May 27, 2003 meeting.
             d. Sale of Non-Buildable Lot at 330 Mason Avenue.               PLANNING Et
                ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To approve the sale of a vacant non-buildable lot (Parcel #24-
205-390-0011-00) at 330 Mason Ave. to Rebia Jackson and Rickey Farmer, 338 Mason
Ave., Muskegon, Ml 49441. Approval of this sale will allow the adjacent property owner
to expand their current yard.     Since the other adjacent property owner wasn't
interested in a portion of the lot, the entire parcel is being offered for $1 to Ms.
Jackson and Mr. Farmer under the new $1 lot program.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: The sale of this lot will allow the property to be placed back on the
City's tax rolls thus relieving the City of continued maintenance costs.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: To approve the resolution and to authorize both the Mayor
and the Clerk to sign the resolution.
             e. Split and Sale of Buildable Lot at 520 E. Isabella Avenue. PLANNING
                Et ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To approve the sale of a vacant buildable lot (Parcel #24-205-
069-0011-00) at 520 Isabella Ave. to Kevin and Roberta Weaver, owners of 1083
Chestnut St., Muskegon, Ml 49442 and Yorvette Price, 1093 Chestnut, Muskegon, Ml
49442. Approval of this sale will allow these two adjacent property owners to expand
their current yards. As is required by City policy, the subject parcel is being offered for
$100 for each half, and the lot will be split between the Weavers and Ms. Price.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: The sale of this lot will allow the property to be placed back on the
City's tax rolls thus relieving the City of continued maintenance costs.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: To approve the resolution and to authorize both the Mayor
and the Clerk to sign the resolution.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: The Land Reutilization Committee approved this
request at their May 27, 2003 meeting.
             f. Annual Carriage License Renewal - Muskegon Carriage Co.           CITY
                CLERK
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To approve the request to license two (2) carriages for
operation in the City of Muskegon for the 2003-2004 licensing year. Sgt. Shirey has
inspected the carriages and approves this request.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: None
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval
             g. Taxicab License Renewal - Port City Cab Company. CITY CLERK
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: This request is from Thomas Wakefield, owner of Wakefield
Leasing, whose office is located at 770 W. Sherman Blvd., Muskegon, Ml. Mr. Wakefield
is requesting approval of an additional taxicab. Sgt. Shirey has inspected the taxicab
and approves this request.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: None
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of an additional taxicab.
             h. Appointment to Various Boards and Committees. CITY CLERK
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To appoint John Thompson and Cara Taylor to the District
Library Board; Eileen Stephanie Allen to the Land Reutilization Committee; and Ernest
Fordham to the Zoning Board of Appeals.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: None
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: To make the appointments.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: The Community Relations Committee recommended the
appointments.
             i. Consideration of Bids - Alpha Street, Commerce to Jefferson.
                ENGINEERING
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: The contract to construct a new paved (Asphalt) street on Alpha
between Commerce & Jefferson be awarded to McCormick Sand Co. out of Shelby.
McCormick Sand was the lowest, responsible bidder with a bid price of $64,427.40.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: The construction cost of $64,427.40 plus related engineering
expenses.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
  STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Award the contract to McCormick Sand Co.
  Motion by Vice Mayor Buie, second by Commissioner Schweifler to approve the
  Consent Agenda as presented.
  ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Warmington,       Buie,   Gawron,   Larson,    Shcweifler,   Shepherd,
             Spataro
               Nays: None
  MOTION PASSED
2003-48 UNFINISHED BUSINESS:
               a. SECOND READING: Rezoning Request for Various Properties to the
                  'MC' Medical Care Zoning District.    PLANNING & ECONOMIC
                  DEVELOPMENT
  SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Request to rezone many of the properties located on or near
  the three hospital campuses within the City from various zoning designations to the new
  "MC" Medical Care Zoning District.
  FINANCIAL IMPACT: None
  BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
  STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff originally proposed a larger area for rezoning around
  the Hackley Hospital area, which included the block bounded by Larch, Leahy, Laketon
  and Hoyt, the block bounded by Larch, Clinton, Laketon and Peck, and several
  properties south of Laketon Ave.
  COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: The Planning Commission recommended approval of the
  request at their 5/15 meeting, with several changes. They voted to approve the
  properties on or near the Hackley Hospital campus as proposed by staff, with the
  exception of all properties currently zoned R-1 (block bounded by Larch, Leahy,
  Laketon and Hoyt, and properties south of Laketon Ave.). That motion passed, with T.
  Harryman and T. Michalski voting nay. They voted then to exclude all properties from
  the block bounded by Larch, Clinton, Laketon and Peck which are not owned by Hackley
  Hospital. That motion passed with B. Mazade, L. Spataro and P. Sartorius voting nay.
  They voted to approve the properties on or near the Mercy-General Health Partners
  Sherman Campus as proposed by staff, with the exception of Dr. Kakaty's office at 2525
  Roberts. That motion passed unanimously. They voted to approve the properties on or
  near the Mercy-General Health Partners Oak Campus as proposed by staff. That motion
  passed unanimously.
  Motion by Commissioner Spataro, second by Vice Mayor Buie to approve the
  ordinance to amend the zoning map of the City to provide for zoning changes for
  certain properties on or near the three hospital campuses within the City to the new
  'MC' Medical Care District.
  ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Buie,       Gawron,    Larson,   Schweifler,     Shepherd,    Spataro,
             Warmington,
               Nays: None
  MOTION PASSED
2003-49   NEW BUSINESS:
               a. Fireworks Display - Muskegon Summer Celebration. CITY CLERK
  SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Steve Franklin is requesting approval of a fireworks display
  permit for July 4th and 6th at the Muskegon Summer Celebration. Fire Marshall Metcalf
  has reviewed the request and recommends approval contingent on inspection of the
  fireworks and approval of the insurance.
  FINANCIAL IMPACT: None
  BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
  STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval contingent on inspection of the fireworks and
  approval of the insurance.
  Motion by Commissioner Shepherd, second by Commissioner Spataro to approve a
  Fireworks Display Permit for Muskegon Summer Celebration to Steve Franklin
  contingent upon approval of insurance and inspection of the Fire Marshall.
  ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Gawron, Larson, Schweifler, Shepherd, Spataro, Warmington,
             Buie
               Nays: None
  MOTION PASSED
               b. Purchase of Garbage Carts (Revised Pricing). PUBLIC WORKS
  SUMMARY OF REQUEST: We have obtained revised pricing for replacement garbage
  carts. Now we have 2 companies competing with equivalent carts. Since we are
  budgeted for 2 truckload purchases in 2003, we recommend that we purchase a
  truckload from each vendor at this time. The cost would be ($38. 90 per cart)
  $20,422.50 from Toter, Inc. and ($38.00 per cart) $20,976.00 from Rehrig Pacific, Inc.
  We will have saved $3,300 from what we paid for carts in 2002. Therefore we request
  that the previous authorization to purchase be rescinded and this proposal be approved.
  FINANCIAL IMPACT: A total of $41,398.50 would be charged to the Sanitation Fund
  BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None, we are budgeted in the Sanitation budget for 2
  annual purchases.
  STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve the purchase.
  Motion by Commissioner Larson, second by Commissioner Gawron to approve the
  request that the previous authorization to purchase replacement garbage carts be
  rescinded and the proposal to purchase the carts from Toter Inc. for $20,422.5 and
  from Rehrig Pacific Inc. for $20,976.00 be approved
  ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Larson,      Schweifler,   Shepherd,   Spataro,   Warmington,    Buie,
             Gawron
               Nays: None
  MOTION PASSED
               c. Consideration of Bids - Nims & Irwin, Getty to Wood. ENGINEERING
  SUMMARY OF REQUEST: The contract to reconstruct Nims St. & resurface Irwin between
  Getty & Wood, using concrete alternative, be awarded to K 8: Rout of Grand Rapids. K
  & R was the lowest, responsible bidder with a bid price of $372,493.38 for the concrete
  alternative.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: The construction cost of $372,493.38 plus related engineering
expenses.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: The up coming quarterly update will have to be revised to
reflect an addition of $100,000 to the budgeted (from $300,000 to $400,000)
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Award the contract to K & R with the concrete alternative.
This recommendation for the use of concrete is based on a slight edge for the concrete
when compared the life cycle versus the cost of both alternatives and the fact that the
existing surface of Nims is concrete.
Motion by Commissioner Larson, second by Commissioner Spataro to award the
contract, with the concrete alternative, for reconstruction of Nims St. and
resurfacing of Irwin between Getty and Wood to K & R of Grand Rapids.
ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Schweifler, Shepherd, Spataro, Warmington, Buie, Gawron,
           Larson
             Nays: None
MOTION PASSED
             d. City Manager's Employment Agreement
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To approve changes to the City Manager's employment
agreement.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: $750 annually
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Changes should be considered in two separate motions.
1) Increase Auto Allowance by $750. Per year
2) Increase Severance Pay from six months to seven months.
Motion by Commissioner Spataro, second by Commissioner Shepherd to approve the
increase of auto allowance by $750 per year in the City Manager's Employment
Agreement.
ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Spataro,      Warmington,     Buie,   Gawron,   Larson,   Schweifler,
           Shepherd
             Nays: None
MOTION PASSED
Motion by Commissioner Spataro, second by Commissioner Schweifler to approve the
            increase severance pay from six months to seven months in the City
            Manager's Employment Agreement.
ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Schweifler, Shepherd, Spataro, Warmington, Buie, Gawron
             Nays: Larson
MOTION PASSED
The Regular Commission Meeting for the City of Muskegon was adjourned at 6:12pm.
                                          Respectfully submitted,

                                            ~~
                                          Gail Kundinger, MMC
Date: June 10, 2003
To:       Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners

From: Finance Director
RE:       Amendment to Non-Union Salary Schedule



SUMMARY OF REQUEST: One component of the recent contract settlement with the
Clerical-Technical Union is the realignment of two positions (Network Technician and Computer
Technician) to non-union status. The nearest salary ranges on the current non-union salary schedule
are either too high or too low to accommodate these positions. Accordingly, staff recommends creation
of a new range V/1-B to meet this need. In line with the recent contract settlement, this change is
recommended to be retroactive to January 1, 2003.

FINANCIAL IMPACT:                 Because of the nature of the work and the access to data, staff
believes it is appropriate and cost-effective for these positions to be non-union. The direct financial
impact of this change is minor. The 2003 non-union salary range will be from $35,019 to $46,695; had
the positions remained in the union, the salary range for 2003 would have been $34,781 to $46,376.

BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED:                       None.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:                       Approval of the proposed amendment to the City's Non-
Union Salary Schedule.

COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:                             None.




9/18/97
                                                              ~
                                            NON-REPRESENTED EMPLOYEES SALARY SCHEDULE


SALARY SCHEDULE
11 STEPS
---
CLASSIFICATION           STEP 1   STEP 2   STEP 3   STEP 4    STEP 5   STEP 6   STEP 7   STEP 8   STEP 9   STEP 10   STEP 11


RANGEi                   61,676   63,732   65,788   67,844   69,900    71,956   74,012   76,068   78,124   80,180    82,236


RANGE II                 56,958   58,857   60,755   62,654   64,552    66,451   68,350   70,248   72,147   74,045    75,944


RANGE lll                52,176   53,901   55,626   57,352   59,077    60,802   62,527   64,252   65,978   67,703    69,428


RANGE IV                 44,945   46,443   47,941   49,439   50,937    52,436   53,934   55,432   56,930   58,428    59,926


RANGE V                  43,018   44,452   45,886   47,321   48,755    50,189   51,623   53,057   54,492   55,926    57,360


RANGE VI                 40,317   41,661   43,005   44,349   45,693    47,038   48,382   49,726   51,070   52,414    53,758


RANGE Vl!•A              37,315   38,559   39,803   41,047   42,291    43,536   44,780   46,024   47,268   48,512    49,756


RANGE Vll-B              35,019   36,187   37,354   38,522   39,689    40,857   42,025   43,192   44,360   45,527    46,695


RANGE VIII               33,037   34,139   35,240   36,342   37,443    38,545   39,646   40,748   41,849   42,951    44,052


RANGE IX                 29,112   30,082   31,053   32,023   32,994    33,964   34,934   35,905   36,875   37,846    38,816


RANGE X                  26,998   27,898   28,798   29,699   30,599    31,499   32,399   33,299   34,200   35,100    36,000


RANGE XJ                 24,584   25,404   26,223   27,043   27,862    28,682   29,502   30,321   31,141   31,960    32,780


JMS·0: EXCEL (2003-3%)
Revised: 5/28/03
                    ADMINISTRATIVE/TECHNICAL/PROFESSIONAL/SUPERVISORY
                                      SALARY RANGES
                                     EFFECTIVE 1/1/2003

                                                    MINIMUM SALARY   MAXIMUM SALARY

RANGEi                                                  $61,676          $82,236

Assistant City Manager
Finance Director
Police Chief
Public Works Director

RANGE II                                                $56,958          $75,944

Community/Economic Development Director
Fire Chief
Leisure Services Director

RANGE Ill                                               $52,176          $69,428

Assistant Chief of Police (Vacant)
City Clerk
City Engineer
City Treasurer
Civil Service/Personnel Director
Deputy Director of Public Works
Information Systems Director

RANGE IV                                                $44,945          $59,926

Assistant Finance Director
Deputy Director of Community/Economic Development
Director of Inspections
Income Tax Director

RANGEV                                                  $43,018          $57,360

Affirmative Action Director
Assistant City Engineer (Vacant)
Community & Neighborhood Services Director
Water Filtration Plant Supervisor

RANGE VI                                                $40,317          $53,758

Building Official (Vacant)
Project Engineer (Vacant)
                                                         MINIMUM SALARY   MAXIMUM SALARY

RANGE VII-A                                                 $37,315          $49,756

Business Development Specialist (Vacant)
Cemetery/Forestry Supervisor
Database Administrator
Equipment Supervisor
Highway Supervisor
Parks Supervisor
Public Utilities Supervisor
Recreation/Marina Supervisor
Safety/Services Supervisor
Special Operations Supervisor
Zoning Administrator

RANGE VII-B                                                 $35,019          $46,695

Computer Technician
Network Technician

RANGE VIII                                                  $33,037          $44,052

Assistant Planner
Communications & Public Affairs Administrator (Vacant)
Income Tax Auditor
Pension & Benefits Coordinator (Part-Time) (Vacant)
Personnel Analyst
Police Community Coordinator
Resource Recovery Coordinator
Revenue Collections Administrator
Risk Manager

RANGE IX                                                    $29,112          $38,816

Building Maintenance Supervisor
Secretary to the City Manager

RANGEX                                                      $26,998          $36,000

Administrative Aide - Police
Administrative Secretary
Administrative Services Supervisor - DPW
Deputy City Clerk
Finance Clerk
Personnel Clerk (Part-Time) (Vacant)
Youth Recreation Coordinator

RANGE XI                                                    $24,584          $32,780

City Hall Building Maintenance Worker

JMS - 0: EXCEL {2003 SALARY RANGES-REVISED 052903)
                  Commission Meeting Date: June 1 O, 2003




Date:         May 30, 2003           d-003 - 7 ~)
                                                L~



To:           Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners

From:         Planning & Economic Development
RE:           Request to Purchase Ta><-Reverted Properties


SUMMARY OF REQUEST:

Prior to 2002, the City was offered many State-owned vacant parcels for purchase for
the price of $300 for the first 5 lots and $20 per lot thereafter. In fact, we recently
submitted a request for 36 lots to the State in March 2003. Shortly after that request
was submitted, the State or Michigan sent us a large list of available properties and
asked if we wished to purchase any of them (see attached letter). Most of the lots that
we requested in March were on this list, however there are additional properties
available. The following list is only the new properties requested. After a call to the
State, we were informed that we could incorporate the two lists and make one request
to purchase properties. One property, #51, which was inadvertently omitted, was
added to this list since the LRC recommended approval.

FINANCIAL IMPACT:

Total cost of these new properties is $1,060, in addition to the $920 already approved
for the previous 36 lots.

BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED:

Expend the additional $1,060 necessary to purchase these parcels.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

To approve the request and to authorize the Mayor and Clerk to sign the attached
resolution.

COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:

The Land Reutilization Committee recommended approval at their May 27, 2003
meeting.




5/30/2003
                                                   ST ATE OF MICHIGAN

JENNIFER M. GRANHOLM           DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES                                             K. L. COOL
      GOVERNOR                                           LANSING                                             DIRECTOR



                                                         April 9, 2003



       Ms. Lonna Anguilm, Assistant Planner
       City of Muskegon
       933 Terrace Street
       P.O.Box 536
       Muskegon,MI 49443-0536

       Dear Ms. Anguilm:

       SUBJECT: STATE-OWNED TAX-REVERTED PROPERTIES

       Attached is a list of the properties we have available for conveyance to your municipality under the
       provisions of Act 451, P.A. 1994, as amended. Included with the list of prope1ties are an application,
       sample resolution and information pertaining to Act 451.

       If you are interested in acquiring title to any of these properties, please submit the application along with
       a resolution passed by your governing body. Your resolution should contain a statement indicating the
       municipality's desire to acquire title to the property and the intended use. The $300.00 application fee
       covers title transfer for 5 parcels. Additional parcels are $20.00 each. In order to expedite the process,
       we are asking that you submit your fee with the application and resolution. The State may withdraw
       parcels from this listing at anytime if they should become unavailable due to redemptions or cancellations
       of deedings to the State.

       The deadline for application for these parcels is June 30, 2003, If we have not received an application
       from you by June 30, 2003, we will assume your municipality has no interest in the property, and it will
       be included in our next available public land auction. Once this prope1ty is placed on our auction listing,
       your application will not be accepted,

       If you have questions regarding this process, please feel free to contact me at the Michigan Depaitment of
       Natural Resources, P.O. Box 30448, Lansing, Michigan 48909-7948 or ai the number provided below.

                                                         Sincerely,



                                                         Ag LAlruhl.0:bz:~~jz:
                                                         Tax Reversion and Land Records
                                                         Office of Land and Facilities
                                                         517-241-2980
       Enclosures




                      STEVENS T. MASON BUILDING • P.O. BOX 30028 • LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7528
                                          www.michigan.gov • (517) 373-2329
                                       Resolution No. -2003= 47 ( c)

                              MUSKEGON CITY COMMISSION


WHEREAS, Act 451, P.A. 1994, as amended, provides for the conveyance of State-owned tax-
reverted lands to municipal units for public purposes; and

WHEREAS, such lands are under the jurisdiction of the State of Michigan, Department of
Natural Resources and are available for acquisition under the provisions of the above mentioned
act; and

WHEREAS, the legal descriptions of these parcels are attached; and

WHEREAS, the City of Muskegon desires to acquire such lands for purposes of residential
developments;

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the City of Muskegon is authorized to make
application to the State of Michigan, Department of Natural Resources, Real Estate Division for
conveyance of said land to the City of Muskegon for a nominal fee as set by the Natural
Resources Commission; and

FURTHER BE IT RESOLVED that the City of Muskegon shall set up necessary procedures and
controls to provide for the property distribution of funds arising from the subsequent sale of the
acquired property in conformity with the above mentioned acts.

Adopted this 10th day of June, 3003.

Ayes: 7

Nays:     O

Absent: o




                                                     Attest: _ _ _ ? , , ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ! C ~ ~
                                                             Gail A. Kundinger, MMC
                                                             Clerk


                                       CERTIFICATION

I hereby certify that the foregoing constitutes a true and complete copy of a resolution adopted
by the City Commission of the City of Muskegon, County of Muskegon, Michigan at a regular
meeting held on June 10, 2003.


                                                             Gail A. Kundinger, MMC
                                                             Clerk
TAX REVERTED PROPERTIES 2003


             Parcel Number                     Address                Lot Size         Buildable          Zoning
                                                                                           ?
   1    24-205-008-0015-00               1994 Continental          40 X 128               No                B-4
  2     24-215-001-0009-00               1858 S. Getty             40 X 128               No                R-1
   3    24-640-000-0017-00               740 E. Holbrook           85 X 80                Yes               R-1
  4     24-205-047-0008-10               874 Williams              33 X 132               No                RT
   5    24-205-628-0009-00               2105 Torrent              18 X 132               No                R-1
   6    24-205-009-0011-10               526 Leonard               44 X 132               No                R-1
   7    24-205-014-0005-00               559 Marquette             50 X 207.29           Yes                R-1
  8     24-205-049-001 ]-10              595 Oak                   60 X 132               Yes               R-1
   9    24-205-079-0003-10               44 3 Catherine            31 X ]32               No                RT
  10    24-205-139-0002-00               388 Jackson               72 X 132               Yes               R-1
  11    24-205-194-0009-00               346 E. Walton             55 X 140              Yes               RM-I
 12     24-205-201-0009-00               302 Orchard               62 X 71                No               RM-1
 13     24-205-236-0001-00               1080 Spring               62 X 70                No               RM-I
 14     24-205-263-0011-00               363 McLaughlin            66 X 132              Yes               RM-I
 15     24-205-264-0002-00               1318 Pine                 60 X 120              Yes               RM-1
 16     24-205-268-0012-00               323 Catawba               66 X 132              Yes               RM-I
 17     24-205-269-0004-00               1317 Wood                 40x 52                 No               RM-I
 18     24-205-417-0014-00               1514 8'"                  50 X 150              Yes                RT
 19     24-205-426-0001-20               151 W. Southern           50 X 100               No                R-1
 20     24-205-045-0009-00               802 Wood                  66 x66                 No                RT
 21     24-205-047-0016-10               873 Scott                 33 X 132               No                RT
 22     24-205-392-0003-10               217 Mason                 44 X 132               No                R-1
 23     24-205-209-0001-00               247 Amity                 31 X 80                No               RM-I
 24     24-205-260-0001-20               261 Catherine             20 X 132               No               RM-1
 25     24-205-292-0025-10               1647 Terrace              51 X 131              Yes                R-1
 26     24-108-400-0005-00               650 Power Line            38.38 acres            Yes              osc
 27     24-205-081-0006-10               550 McLaughlin            76x 66                 No                R-1
 28     24-769-000-0023-00               604 Orchard               56 X 121               Yes               R-1
 29     24-205-035-0001-00               739 Ellifson              40x214               No(odd)             R-1
 30     24-205-037-0001-06               734 Wesley                40 X ]25               No                R-1
 31     24-205-015-0005-00               609 Marquette             66 x67                 No                R-1
 32     24-205-208-0013-10               164 Allen                 33 X 132               No               RM-1
 33     24-205-206-0011-00               186 Myrtle                66 X 140               Yes              RM-I
 34     24-205-201-0002-10               305 Myrtle                45 X 80                No               RM-1
 35     24-205-269-0001-10               373 Catawba               60 X 66                No               RM-I
 36     24-205-252-0012-00               185 E. Isabella           66 X 132               Yes              RM-I
 37     24-205-242-0012-00               35 Iona                   34 X 132               No               RM-I
 38     24-205-414-0015-00               704 W. Southern           50 X 80                No                RT
 39     24-205-480-0003-00               1057 Washington           50 X 165               Yes               RT
 40     24-205-206-0001-00               181 E. Walton             66 X 140               Yes               R-1


O:\Planning\COMMON\Property\Property Acquisitions\Tax-Reverlcd Property Acquisition\T AX REVERTED PROPERTIES 2003-
final.doc
  41    24-205-040-0011-20                768 Scott                 66 X    99             Yes             R-1
  42    24-205-090-0006-00                667 Hill                  50 X    96             No              R-1
  43    24-205-064-0012-00                644 Ada                   66 X    ]65            No              R-1
  44    24-205-264-0007-10                1293 Spring               36 X    90             No             RM-I
  45    24-675-003-0009-00                1867 Hoyt                 50 X    ]25            Yes             R-1
  46    24-771-000-0030-00                1294 Williams             78 X    ]88            Yes             RT
  47    24-611-000-0234-00                1325 Wesley               50 X    131.85         Yes             R-1
  48    24-613-000-0827-00                1355 Leonard              47 X    ]24            No              R-1
  40    24-860-000-0052-00                2155 Continental          56 X    ]28            Yes             R-1
  50    24-860-000-0141-00                2240 Austin               5] X    ]28            Yes             R-1
  51    24-205-044-0010-10                438 Oak                 , 33 X    132            No              RT


Prope1ties with homes on them (requested by CNS for rehab).


             Parcel Number                     Address                Lot Size        Buildable        Zoning       Dangerous
                                                                                            ?                        Building
                                                                                                                      List(?)
   I    24-142-000-000700                1013 Amity                60   X   132           Yes            R-1            No
   2    24-205-079-0002-10               453 Catherine             33   X   132           No             RT            Yes




O:\Planning\COMMON\Propcrty\Property Acquisitions\Tax~Reverted Property Acquisition\TAX REVERTED PROPERTIES 2003~
final.doc
                                          ~ oo~ - <-\ 7
                   Commission Meeting Date: June 1 O, 2003
                                                               dJ

Date:          May 30, 2003
To:            Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners

From:          Planning & Economic Development
RE:            Sale of Non-buildable Lot at 330 Mason Avenue


SUMMARY OF REQUEST:

To approve the sale of a vacant non-buildable lot (Parcel #24-205-389-0011-00) at 330
Mason Avenue to Rebia Jackson and Rickey Farmer, 338 Mason Avenue, Muskegon,
Ml 49441 Approval of this sale will allow the adjacent property owner to expand their
current yard (see attached map). Since the other adjacent property owner wasn't
interested in a portion of the lot, the entire parcel is being offered for $1 to Ms. Jackson
and Mr. Farmer under the new $1 lot program.

FINANCIAL IMPACT:

The sale of this lot will allow the property to be placed back on the City's tax rolls thus
relieving the City of continued maintenance costs.

BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED:

None.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

To approve the attached resolution and to authorize both the Mayor and the Clerk to
sign the resolution.

COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:




5/30/2003
                                    CITY OF MUSKEGON

                                     RESOLUTION #2003- 4 7          (d)


RESOLUTION APPROVING THE SALE OF A CITY-OWNED NON-BUILDABLE LOT

WHEREAS, the City of Muskegon has received $1 from Rebia Jackson and Rickey Farmer, 338
Mason Street, Muskegon, MI 49441 for the purchase of a vacant, City-owned lot located
adjacent to her property at 330 Mason Avenue (parcel #24-205-389-001 l-00);

WHEREAS, this lot is not considered buildable under the City's Zoning Ordinance,

WHEREAS, the sale would enable the City to place this property back on the tax rolls, and
would relieve the City of further maintenance;

WHEREAS, the sale of this property would be in accordance with property disposition goals and
the Area 10 $1 lot program;

NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that THE CITY OF MUSKEGON REVISED PLAT
OF 1903 W ½ LOT 11 BLK 389 be sold to Rebia Jackson and Rickey Farmer for $1.


Resolution adopted this 10111 day of June, 2003.

        Ayes:    7

       Nays:     o

       Absent:




       Gail A. Kundinger, MMC
       Clerk

                                       CERTIFICATION

This resolution was adopted at a regular meeting of the City Commission, held on June 10, 2003. The
meeting was properly held and noticed pursuant to the Open Meetings Act of the State of Michigan,
Act 267 of the Public Acts of 1976.

                                                     CITY OF MUSKEGON



                                               By
                                                            Gail A. Kundinger, MM
                                                            Clerk
                                                       QUIT-CLAIM DEED
                                                             2003-47 (d)
KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: That the CITY OF MUSKEGON, a municipal corporation, whose address is 933
Terrace Street, Muskegon, MI 49440,

QU[T CLAIMS TO: REBIA JACKSON, a single woman, and RICKEY FARMER, a single man, of338 Mason Avenue,
Muskegon, Michigan 49441,

the following described premises situated in the City of Muskegon, County of Muskegon, State of Michigan, to wit:

                 City of Muskegon Revised Plat of 1903, West½ of Lot 11 Block 389

for the sum of: Less Than $100

This deed is exempt from real estate transfer tax pursuant to the provisions ofMCLA 207.505(h)(i) and MCLA 207.526 Sec. 6(h)(i).

Dated this lOthday of    June         , 2003

                                                             CITY OF MUSKEGO

                                                             By
                                                               Steph




STATE OF MlCHIGAN
COUNTY OF MUSKEGON

         The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this --1.,l;A day of , T,.     , 2003, by Stephen J.
Warmington and Gail A. Kundinger, MMC, Mayor and City Clerk, respectively, of the CITY OF MUSKEGON, a municipal
corporation, on behalf of the City.


PREPARED BY:
John C. Schrier                                              Notary Public, Muskegon County, Michigan
Parmenter O'Toole                                            My commission expires:    1/ -,-. -:-.
                                                                                         7 5~~ i;:·: (

175 W. Apple Ave., P. 0. Box 786
Muskegon,MI49443-0786
Telephone: 6 I 6-722-1621

SEND SUBSEQUENT TAX BILLS TO: Grantee                                  WHEN RECORDED RETURN TO: Grantee
                   Commission Meeting Date: June 1 0, 2003




Date:          May 28, 2003
To:            Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:          Planning & Economic Development              ~
RE:           Split and Sale of Buildable Lot at 520 E. Isabella Avenue


SUMMARY OF REQUEST:

To approve the split and sale of a vacant buildable lot (Parcel #24-205-069-0011-00) at
520 Isabella Avenue to Kevin & Roberta Weaver, owners of 1083 Chestnut Street,
Muskegon, Ml 49442 and Yorvette Price, 1093 Chestnut, Muskegon, Ml 49442.
Approval of this sale will allow these two adjacent property owners to expand their
current yards (see attached map). As is required by City policy, the subject parcel is
being offered for $100 for each half, and the lot will be split between the Weavers and
Ms. Price.

FINANCIAL IMPACT:

The sale of this lot will allow the property to be placed back on the City's tax rolls thus
relieving the City of continued maintenance costs.

BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED:

None.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

To approve the attached resolution and to authorize both the Mayor and the Clerk to
sign the resolution.

COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:

The Land Reutilization Committee (LRC) approved this request at their May 27, 2003
meeting.




5/28/2003
                                   CITY OF MUSKEGON

                                    RESOLUTION #2002- 47          (e)


RESOLUTION APPROVING THE SALE OF A CITY-OWNED BUILDABLE LOT

WHEREAS, the City of Muskegon has received $100 each from Kevin and Roberta Weaver,
owners of 1083 Chestnut Street, Muskegon, MI 49442 and Yorvette Price, 1093 Chestnut Street,
Muskegon, MI 49442 for the purchase of a vacant, City-owned lot located adjacent to their
properties at 520 E. Isabella A venue (parcel #24-205-069-0011-00);

WHEREAS, this lot is considered buildable under the City's Zoning Ordinance; and

WHEREAS, the adjacent property owners homes are located on unbuildable lots and the addition
of this property would expand their yards and result in creating buildable lots; and

WHEREAS, the sale would enable the City to place this property back on the tax rolls; and
would relieve the City of fmiher maintenance;

WHEREAS, the sale of this property would be in accordance with prope1iy disposition goals and
policies of the City;

NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, CITY OF MUSKEGON REVISED PLAT OF 1903
W ½ LOTS 11 & 12 BLK 69 be sold to Kevin & Roberta Weaver and Yorvette Price for $100
for each one-half lot.


Resolution adopted this 10th day of June, 2003.

       Ayes: 7.:,

       Nays:     O

       Absent:      0




       Gail A. Kw1dinger, MMC
       Clerk
                                      CERTIFICATION

This resolution was adopted at a regular meeting of the City Commission, held on June 10, 2003. The
meeting was properly held and noticed pursuant to the Open Meetings Act of the State of Michigan,
Act 267 of the Public Acts of 1976.

                                                     CITY OF MUSKEGON



                                             By
                                                       QUIT-CLAIM DEED
                                                           2003-47 (e)
KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: That the CITY OF MUSKEGON, a municipal corporation, whose address is 933
Terrace Street, Muskegon, MI 49440,

QUIT CLAIMS TO: KEVIN WEAVER AND ROBERTA WEAVER, husband and wife, of P.O. Box 49, Newaygo, Michigan
49337,

the following described premises situated in the City of Muskegon, County of Muskegon, State of Michigan, to wit:

                  City of Muskegon Revised Plat of 1903, West½ of Lot 12 Block 69

for the sum of: Less Than $ I 00

This deed is exempt from real estate transfer tax pursuant to the provisions ofMCLA 207.505(h)(i) and MCLA 207.526 Sec. 6(h)(i).

Datedthis lOt\'layof June             , 2003




STATE OF MICHIGAN
COUNTY OF MUSKEGON

         The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 1'l_ day of ~        , 2003, by Stephen J.
Warmington and Gail A. Kundinger, MMC, Mayor and City Clerk, respectively, oftCITYOF MUSKEGON, a municipal
corporation, on behalf of the City.

                                                             ~ ~ Y Y ) . ~ ~ ..                        x:.:
PREPARED BY:                                                  S1 C:i no YY-.. 1-'b\<(j
John C. Schrier                                              Notaiy Public, Muskegon County, Michigan
Parmenter 01Toole                                            My commission expires:   5 - I ""!:.- D '5"-
175 W. Apple Ave., P. 0. Box 786
Muskegon, MI 49443-0786
Telephone: 616-722-1621

SEND SUBSEQUENT TAX BILLS TO: Grantee                                WHEN RECORDED RETURN TO: Grantee
                                                       QUIT-CLAIM DEED
                                                        2003-47 (e)

KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: That the CITY OF MUSKEGON, a municipal corporation, whose address is 933
Terrace Street, Muskegon, MI 49440,

QUIT CLAIMS TO: YORVETTE PRICE, a single woman, of 1093 Chestnut Street, Muskegon, MI 49442

the following described premises situated in the City of Muskegon, County of Muskegon, State of Michigan, to wit:

                 City of Muskegon Revised Plat of 1903, West½ of Lot I I Block 69

for the sum of: Less Than $ I 00

This deed is exempt from real estate transfer tax pursuant to the provisions ofMCLA 207.505(h)(i) and MCLA 207.526 Sec. 6(h)(i).

Datedthis 10t1olayof June             , 2003




                                                                Gail A. Kundinger, MMC, City Clerk

STATE OF MICHIGAN
COUNTY OF MUSKEGON

         The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this J.'}_ day of   2'½±             ,
                                                                                           2003, by Stephen J.
Warmington and Gail A. Kundinger, MMC, Mayor and City Clerk, respectively, oftHe CITY OF MUSKEGON, a municipal
corporation, on behalfof the City.


PREPARED BY:
John C. Schrier                                              Notary Public, Muskegon County, Michigan
Parmenter O'Toole                                            My commission expires:   S"- \::,,- D'5
175 W. Apple Ave., P. 0. Box 786
Muskegon, MI 49443-0786
Telephone: 616-722-1621

SEND SUBSEQUENT TAX BILLS TO: Grantee                                WHEN RECORDED RETURN TO: Grantee
Vacant Buildable City-Owned Lot                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             N


520 Isabella Avenue                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        W~E

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            s
                                                                                                                                                    ,                 , , 1 ,, 1· ,                                                 ai                      i         .i ,                                        I I      :i:1 , ,i r~
                                                 '                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          1           ,                I                          I


                                                                                                                                                    '
                                                                                                                                                    I                 I           I I           52
                                                                                                                                                                                                     I.,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    I
                                                                                                                                                                                                               I 111 00
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      •
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               I          1 I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Lr;;__j........66......~•~ub11~I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  1 1· 1••c~~~·
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             I I ' ~~~~~~~~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     I
                                                                                                                                                                                          EAPPLEAV
  ~'I                                                                        •                   • I • I •                            !
                                                                                                                                                   I,
                                                                                                                                                        •
                                                                                                                                                                  I
                                                                                                                                                                          "I" I             I" i • I " • I
                                                                                                                                                                                           I '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  o,w                      I    I "'   I          '"      I • ., !., I • I • I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             I I I ' '
           .•           .. .
                                                                                                           ,,; '
                                                                                                           1· . ·.•.·•.. I       ,,
                                                                                                                                   I
                                                                                                                                                   h                          I I
                                                                                                                                                                                                      I
                                                                                                                                                                                                               i          I I                          ,1                                                                  I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                !      I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          s I 'F                                                'H                           ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         i----1,
  Y '.
 I~
                             '
                                                                                                 •.
                                                                                                 w
                                                                                                                       i          I

                                                                                                                                                   ,• •           '
                                                                                                                                                                              I,
                                                                                                                                                                                                     '              I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                .'·
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ,,w
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           !~1111~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           I I•        ! •I I.,                                            "'                   I '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         LJ
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ----;---

    ~
  "\~
                            •
                                             P=-,--1
                                             IL=f I
                                             '
                                                                                                                                 'I                b
                                                                                                                                                   e---,•,••····

                                                                                                                                                   I ' ,.,
                                                                                                                                                              ..'                     I '!I
                                                                                                                                                                                      I  k;·' ·1' • 'I!
                                                                                                                                                                                      A AKV      [)'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1.·
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1                                                                                      I

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                F
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                •

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       !I · '.II
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   I!
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ~·:  '111
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         '

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         1'.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       I

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       I   •

  l,A' ,j                                k• 1 • ! •                                            •I. I                                                    • . • • I" I" I" I Kevin&RobertaWeaver                                                                                                                                                         I"' • =f"l
                                                                                                                                               ~
                                                                                         1   • •




  :')    ..1•.:.
  ..•\·A,•.•                                                  I         I                1I : I I ,1                                                    ... · : I ,i 1 .~ 1083 Chestnut                                                                                                                                                               , ,! '.i1 ,U                                                                       kT"°
  1/.        1   i 1 --; •
                                     1
                                         n   !


                                      . 1 · .. 1 ~ -
                         -::::;;;:;==;::;;=;:::;;::;=;;=_
  •\ t:I. ~~~;=;=;==; I,..__.1                            .'
                                                          I
                                                                                                                                                              1                                                                                                                                                          ,       1 1 'i ,1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       I --=::~:=:~I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       11--..;, I 17. - ,r4'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         i-----1,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         LJ                     *= Subject Property(ies)
      \:~
                                   "'1··1 .. 1- ....
                                         ,c--,
                                         !                    i             I I                             ,    •   i                                                                I i                          el.*w        I ..

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      I                                                        H
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               e
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       '                     ,1                 w                    1' -_I'                           to be sold

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ~~~~--
                                         F I
                                         1                    1             I I                       Yorvette Price I                                                                                             '•· ··.      1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  •I                                                                   I               !                               1               I         I              I                    '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ;-1           I       I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           I




  ~;,•~, L
  /•
  '
  '·.~·
           '




                    gl
                                     '
                                      1 •
                                                 •                '"




                                                                       ,
                                                                             "



                                                          1· I . ,1. I . ! . !
                                                                                             '




                                                                                          tf---1 :
                                                                                     1,1,1(/:f:,
                                                                                                 ,1
                                                                                                       1093Chestnut

                                                                                                                      Y
                                                                                                                                               I            •• , • ' ""I., I
                                                                                                                                                                                                     E ISABELLAAV

                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ,L____,J
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ,:..+1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                &_j
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      I. I·
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              i I i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          !
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ~'I•''
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              1·1·1 ·I .. , I · 1. !"I"• • • I . I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     w
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   I 1       I •I                                  j



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              1 1~g1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ,I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 LLJ
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 I")"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 i'--J
      ~                 I
                                     I                    i                          I           I ,.  '                  I           :z
                                                                                                                               I ! ~_,j I           I I                               '                                                                                                                                                                                          I   :r:\=- :;=;:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       I                                     =.
  ./                                 h
                                     f
                                                          I                 /1
                                                                            I I
                                                                                                 l'~nll)I                      1.~~'1~ 1 111 1,!1,               !

                                                                                                 I ~ : : ! ' - ,,,l,,i .1,,, • 1 _, Uj• I., I j J,, i,,, 1 W__.,_L I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ,i    , alf-i 111
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       I                                    I~~
  A\F.R60NAI. A I\OV INJU!t'l'
                                                                                                                                                                                                              ...
                                                                                                                                                                  ~EN~RALA@G~8GATF.                       :$
         -r)l:N'I. A()(_:\Af;/j;Ajl; W.tff APPi.Ji.$ Pl.:R:                                                                                                        pRQPucTs. cor.,r:-10~ AGG J $
             . ·1 eOLICV f7 l!'8i litCC
 A       --
          AUTOMOBILE LII\BILITY
                  /lf.NAl,ITO
                  Jit,1, OWN~Q IIUTOS
                                                              TCA0005573
                                                                                                            !
                                                                                                            ' 03/01/03                               03/01/04 ,--.
                                                                                                                                                                  COMBINED SIN@LE I.IMIT
                                                                                                                                                                  jr.c~cci-Famlly Residential
                                                                           -----L     ~
                                                                                                                                                               Morcy-G-ral Health Partners
                                                                                                                                                               Oak campus Ania

                                                                                                                                                                                                                •     Boundary of Proposed
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      MC District(s)

                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Notice Area for
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Proposed Rezoning
D      RM-1: Low Density Multiple-Family Residential
0      RM-2: Medium Density Multiple-Family Residential                                                       ti
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              N
12]1 RM-3:
LJPUOO,ertay
               High Density Multiple-Family Residential
                                                                                                              I                         Village at
                                                                                                                                        the Oaks

D      E>-1: Um~ed Business
                                                                                                                   Oakview
CJ B-2: Convenience and Comparison Business                                                                        Medical


                                                                           ~
D      E>-3: central Business
                                                                                                                   Center                    Medical
D      E>-4: General Business
                                                                                                                                             Offices
[ZZJ E>-5:   Governmental Services                                                                                    Mercy-General
D      e1: Light Industrial                                                                                           Health Partners
D e2: General Industrial                                                                                               Oak Campus
                                                                                                                                             Medical Medical
I'/ ,I WI-PUD: waterfront lndustrtal Planned Unit Development                                                                                                                                                   City of Muskegon
LJ OSC: Open Space Conservation                                                                                                              Offices Offices                                                    Proposed Medical Care
m] CSR:       Open Space Recreation
                                                                                                                                                                                                                Zoning Districts
c:J LR:      Lakelront Recreation                                                                                                       ~
C] WIM:       waterfront Manne
D H : Herttage                                                                                                                                                                                                  As amended by
                                                                                                                                                                                                                Planning Commission
                                                                                                                                                                                                                May 15, 2003
                                      Staff Report [EXCERPT]
                                       CITY OF MUSKEGON
                                     PLANNING COMMISSION
                                       REGULAR MEETING
                                             May 15, 2003


Hearing; Case 2003-18: Staff-initiated request to rezone the three hospital campuses in the
City from various zoning designations to the new MC, Medical Care district.


BACKGROUND
This rezoning is the continuation of the process began by adoption of the new Medical Care
(MC) district language several months ago. Staff has studied the three hospital campuses and
surrounding uses, and is proposing tlu·ee areas to be rezoned to the new district. These areas
include existing medically-related uses, as well as areas which may realistically better be served
as medically related. The intention was to recognize the existing hospital campus locations and
to also provide some areas for hospital growth.

The tlu·ee areas are summarized in more detail below, based on the hospital campus location:
•   Mercy-General Health Partners - Oak Campus (Oak Ave. and Harvey St.)
    Most of the existing hospital campus is currently zoned RM-I, with a small portion zoned
    RM-2. Staff is also proposing to include the Village at the Oaks and Oakview Medical
    Center properties as well, as these uses are also currently zoned RM-I, fit well within the MC
    district and are directly adjacent to the hospital campus proper. Staff did not include other
    adjacent properties, such as the Carriage House and Glen Oaks apartment complexes
    (currently zoned RM-2) and the MAISD property (currently zoned RM-I). The proposed
    district bounds Muskegon Township to the south.
•   Mercy-General Health Partners-Sherman Campus (Sherman Blvd. and US-31)
    Most of this hospital campus is also currently zoned RM-I, with a small portion of
    unimproved property zoned I-2. Staff is also proposing to include several adjacent medical
    office buildings as shown on the enclosed map. Most of these are currently zoned RM- I as
    well, with a few zoned B-2, and one property currently zoned B-1. Staff did not include any
    properties within the Medendorp Industrial Park which are current industrial uses. The
    proposed district bounds Norton Shores to the south.
•   Hackley Hospital (Laketon Ave., Larch Ave., Hoyt St., Clinton St., and Peck St. area)
    Most of this hospital campus is also currently zoned RM- I, with portions zoned R-1 and RM-
    2 as well. Staff is also proposing to include several existing medical office buildings directly
    adjacent to the campus on Peck St. and Larch Ave. which are currently zoned B-4. There is
    one residential property in this area as well. Staff is also proposing to include some medical
    office and residential properties to the southeast of the campus, and across Laketon Ave., all
    currently zoned R-1. The intention is to give the hospital some room for controlled
    expansion as homes may come up for sale.



City of Muskegon Planning Commission - 5/15/03
Staff has received several phone calls and letters regarding this case. The letters are attached for
review. The phone calls are summarized below:
        • Dr. and Ms. Kakaty, 2525 Robe1is St., ve1y opposed to their building being included
             in the rezoning as this would limit their options for sale of the building.
        • Chris, Shoreline Opthamology, Sherman Blvd., had questions about the proposed
             rezoning and no objections to it. He also stated that the little piece of prope1iy shown
             on the map as 'MGHP' behind their building is in fact owned by them.
        • Marvin De Winter, owner of the Oakview Medical Center, had questions about how
             the proposed rezoning would affect his prope1iy. He had no objections to the
             rezonmg.
        • David Tencate asked for a copy of the MC zoning district regulations. The district
             language was e-mailed to him.
        • One caller on Jiroch St. had questions about the rezoning but did not leave a name or
             address.
        • One caller had questions about the rezoning but did not leave a name or address.
        • One caller had many questions about the rezoning and the new Hackley ER building
             and proposed helipmi. He stated that he lives near Hackley Hospital but did not wish
             to leave a name or address. He had questions about what the new district means for
           · the neighborhood.


DELIBERATION
Criteria-based questions typically asked during a rezoning include:

1. What, if any, identifiable conditions related to the petition have changed which justify the
   petitioned change in zoning.

2. What are the precedents and the possible effects of precedent which might result from the
   approval or denial of the petition.

3. What is the impact of the amendment on the ability of the city to provide adequate public
   services and facilities and/or programs that might reasonably be required in the future if the
   petition is approved.

4. Does the petitioned zoning change adversely affect the environmental conditions or value of
   the sunounding property.

5. Does the petitioned zoning change generally comply with the adopted Future Land Use
   Plan of the City.

6. Are there any significant negative environmental impacts which would reasonably occur if
   the petitioned zoning change and resulting allowed structures were built such as:

               a.      Surface water drainage problems
               b.      Waste water disposal problems


City of Muskegon Planning Commission-5/15/03                                                        2
                c.     Adverse effect on surface or subsurface water quality
                d.     The loss of valuable natural resources such as forest, wetland, historic
                       sites, or wildlife areas.

7. Is the proposed zoning change a "Spot Zone"?

               a.      Is the parcel small in size relative to its surroundings?
               a.      Would the zoning change allow uses that are inconsistent with those
                       allowed in the vicinity?
               b.      Would the zoning change confer a benefit to the property owner that is
                       not generally available to other properties in the area?
               c.      A spot zone is appropriate if it complies with the Master Plan.




City of Muskegon Planning Commission-5/15/03                                                 3
Date:      June 10, 2003
To:        Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:      Gail A. Kundinger, City Clerk
RE:        Fireworks Display - Muskegon Summer
           Celebration




SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Steve Franklin is requesting approval of a
fireworks display permit for July 4th and 6th at the Muskegon Summer
Celebration. Fire Marshall Metcalf has reviewed the request and
recommends approval contingent on inspection of the fireworks and
approval of the insurance.



FINANCIAL IMPACT: None.



BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.



STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval contingent on inspection of the
fireworks and approval of the insurance.
                                                              2003-49 (a)
                                                              PERMIT
                                         FOR FIREWORKS DISPLAY
                                             Act 358, P.A. 1968
            This permit is not transferable. Possession of this permit by the herein named person will
          authorize him to possess, transport and display fireworks in the amounts, for the purpose, and
                                           at the place listed below only.


  TYPE OF DISPLAY:                       (X)       PUBLIC DISPLAY                                  ( ) AGRlCULTURAL PEST CONTROL

ISSUED TO:                           -   ---
                                           •
NAME
              STEVE FRANKLIN
ADDRESS                                                                              AGE
           3500 S. GETTY

REPRESENTING
NA,',!E OF OROA..'


                                                       ( Subject t o Approval of Loca l Fire Authorities!

                                                             I A.   AMOUNT OF BONO OR INS U RAN CE
7. FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY                                         1 to be set by munic ipal i ty)           $
  B. BONDING CORPORATION OF            I NSURANCE COMPANY: NAME                     ADDRESS
                                                                   JUN-09-2003 15: 22                                     FRANKLIN'S                                                                    P. 03

                                                                                                                        CERTIFICATE·O!'INSURANCE .




                                                                                                                                                                                        1.1111ft

                                                                                     .. ·GP511Al-1-IAR.ffY
                                                                                     .     CLAJMSKUK

     ..             :                                              ~-                                                  'DMCLWOJOI"     12131»/lOIIZ
                                                       . . i·
    ;;\ .                          ' •            .



                                                                                                                                                                                                    J

                                                                                                                                                                                                    s

                                                                                                                                                                                                    I
                                                                                                       VAam'
                                                                              .              ·:~ Y e t M
    ··: ·.•·                                            '    .            '
                                                                              ·,· 1:; '
                                                                                   '
                                                                                                   '



                                                                                                        CGIMM.\TION
    :_
    .·•;:·!


    < .•
        ••. ···~./:· ::.:_::_




    1, :: -:,             '        .
                                                             ,;)_·;-:·.: ~UUJl,m
                            :·.. ~. :,:._,.·_- :,· :.:_'.~,: / , ;:' .... _\: :          : ~

                                                                                                                                                                    U..fAat~ . : . .
                                                                                                                                                                    u...........          ..
    ,'
    :·
         ::. :•'~·:
    ~     ;         ;':       '        l   . '.       •:,, : •::      : /•:~ ,, ,:

                                                                               ·'.: ;    . . .:·
     ·.':: .· .·..i ·:.                                                                                W~110Ni4.0CAT(Ol'fSM:HICUJI/                   N   RUA1ENTIIPECW. PROl'.JSJONI     · :            . . .
·:,.' . · ·. ·.::yiJ.~?Y:81....JJ •             ~•~__,:and •ppoietcd 111 volu'"'1,1U Nn:I of coatmmionuo1111iorJt1euu ilKir.~'!I ·
         · • · , ·..• ·-~ ~)111!1!1 •~ vof111tieri2) CtJ1111Cry or Mwkep111 l~ Mmlu!&OI Suanm Ctlebradoa. ~•pfo,.s ..d ;YO~ ,f) ~ -.
         ··. . ..·, : !'~     ...... 5) Marliel Cnrp 1n Addltion8l l11i11rtde n ......... • Fircworka Pitplay o• JtlJ f, 20D:I (RD Jlif1, S, ~ - 1 .
                                              :··::Mia·.••• Lib Nardlofl&ritap Ltillllln&,




                                                                              .,   ·,
: ' • ,;                                                              .        ~ '      ..
                                            .. . !,,-- -~-· - - -- -
                                                    · ;~                                                     - ---~--.....L------------~-L...!2~1.o11~..U.C-:~~efl,4:,f.:.'-----.....J

         ...
0

i~            t '                 :- •            .·.            •,

: -•.• .:-.·:••                                             ,·
                                                                                                                                                                                                   TOTAL P.03
                                        JUN-09-2003           15=21              FRANKLIN'S                                                                      P. 02

                                                                               C£RTIFICATE'                                              .ISSUI DAff J1• e t, ~




                                                                                                     ~C:

                                        . . :::   ,•,'




                                                                               NIIUn/fUMWtl


                                                                                                                                                           . Sl

                                                                                                 1200l'J003
           .,    ':   ··,: •,}·" .,..
   ;. :;:-·..i             /L ,: _.:

                                                                                                                                                           I .
                                                                                                                                   IIOIIII.Y~       ·      S',
                                                                                                                                               DUIAGS      ,..
                                                                                                                                                           s
                                                                                                                                                           J.




       .               • ·                        ·      ..    110    1.0('ATI0NSIYt QCl.1..&t'.XCLIJ9bNADDZD IIW I   ll&t"ME   IQPf'.Cl,\J.
       ' ..: ; :: h...,_ :ir,..•._11 & 1U eleetld aud appointed tlJ foh1111JM,. 1111 ho.rd ofcomttlalonl on llldflurila.1111 Mt,board                                .
 .· ··. ·.                : ! .~  .eiilplDy• 1od vol••teen 2) Cuu•cry ofM.......113) M ~ S1,111111m Ce.tehn11io1.em~.a.,.S;'N lu..., 4) W•
       ·                · . Mill- D,il,lk S)Mt~ Corp art Md.ltloM.l lnurtd1 a Rapectl t Fi~orli& Dl1play "" Jat, 6, 2tlOJ (11D .IIIJy T, lal)-.
                       · : ....... i,kl Ntr11t cf lkritqe.Ltldi11c,




                           ·,
   •       •    • '     • ' V




ri~i{} :}·I..
Date:         June 3, 2003
To:           Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:         Public Works
RE:           Purchase of Garbage Carts (Revised Pricing)


SUMMARY OF REQUEST:
We have obtained revised pricing for replacement garbage carts. Now we have 2
companies competing with equivalent carts. Since we are budgeted for 2 truckload
purchases in 2003, we recommend that we purchase a truckload from each vendor
at this time. The cost would be ($38.90 per cart) $20,422.50 from Toter, Inc. and
($38.00 per cart) $20,976.00 from Rehrig Pacific, Inc. We will have saved $3,300
from what we paid for carts in 2002. Therefore we request that the previous
authorization to purchase be rescinded and this proposal be approved.

FINANCIAL IMPACT:
A total of $41,398.50 would be charged to the Sanitation Fund.

BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED:
None, we are budgeted in the Sanitation budget for 2 annual purchases.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Approve the purchase.

COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION




9/18/97
                                                                  Public Works




Memo
 To:      Robert Kuhn, DPW Director
 From:    Bob Fountain, Special Operations Supervisor
 Date:    06/04/03
 Re:      Purchase of Replacement Garbage Carts



 At the previous City Commission meeting held on May 27, 2003 we presented a proposal to purchase
 525 garbage carts from Toter, Inc., which is our long-lime vendor of carts. The price quoted was $42.00
 each for a total of $22,050 delivered to the Public Service Building. This proposal was approved. Since
 that lime we have been contacted by Rehrig Pacific, Inc., which manufactures the garbage carts used
 by our contractor, Sunset Waste Services, for its other customers. We have examined this cart and
 found it to be suitable for use in the City. Rehrig Pacific quoted a price of $38.00 per cart for a truckload
 of 552 carts. Since the price of the Rehrig Pacific cart is significantly lower than the price quoted for the
 Toter cart, we contacted Toter and asked them to match the lower price. Now Toter comes back with a
 new price of $38.90 per cart delivered. It this point we believe we have very good prices for essentially
 equivalent equipment and each with a 10-year guarantee. Keep in mind that in 2002 we purchased 2
 truckloads of carts from Toter at $44.37 per cart.

 I am proposing that we purchase a truckload of carts from each of these vendors, Rehrig Pacific and
 Toter. We are budgeted in 2003 for 2 truckloads so we can significantly replace dilapidated or broken
 carts. As we do with water meters, our policy is to purchase from competing vendors so that we receive
 ihe best pricing possible. In 2002 we spent $44,724.96 on cart purchases. This year we will be able to
 spend less, $41,398.50. That is a savings of $3,326.46. Below is a summary of the quoted prices.



 Vendor                             Price per    # Purchased        Total Expense
                                    cart

 Toter (Bell Equipment Co.)         38.90        525                20,422.50

 Rehrig Pacific                     38.00        552                20,976.00

 Total                                                              41,398.50
Date:        June 10, 2003
To:          Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:        Engineering
RE:          Consideration of Bids
             Nims & Irwin Getty to Wood


SUMMARY OF REQUEST:
The contract to reconstruct Nims Street & resurface Irwin between Getty & Wood, using
concrete alternative, be awarded to K & R out of Grand Rapids. K & R was the lowest,
see attached bid tabulation, responsible bidder with a bid price of $372,493.38 for the
concrete alternative.



FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The construction cost of $372,493.38 plus related engineering expenses.



BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED:
The up coming quarterly update will have to be revised to reflect an addition of $100,000
to the budgeted (from $300,000 to $400,000).


STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Award the contract to K & R with the concrete alternative. This recommendation , use of
concrete, is based on a slight edge for the concrete when compared the life cycle verses the
cost of both alternatives and the fact that the existing surface of Nims is concrete.



COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:
                                                                          H-1564 NIMS & IRWIN, WOOD ST. TO GETTY ST.
                                                                         BID TABULATION -CONCRETE 05/20/03 - PAGE 1
                                                      CONTRACTOR        JACKSON-MERKEY     KAMMINGA & ROODVOETS PRINCE BRIDGE & MARINE          FELCO CONTRACTORS           .. ~~"" 0'
                                                       ST ADDRESS     555 E. WESTERN AVE.      3435 BROAD MOOR AVES          PO BOX 510           874 PULASKI AVE.             2500 OCEANA DR
                                                         CITY/ST/ZIP USKEGON, Ml 49442~103 GRAND RAPIDS, Ml 49512 GRAND HAVEN, Ml 49417         MUSKEGON, Ml 49441           HART, Ml 49420~8116
                    DESCRIPTION                   QUANTIT     UNIT    UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE         UNIT PRICE     TOTAL PRICE
 1   ADJUST CATCH BASIN CASTING                        4      EACH        $300.00    $1,200.00     $300,00    $1,200.00   $325.00    $1,300.00    $350.00     $1,400.00       $300.00        $1,200.00
 2   ADJUST MANHOLE CASTING                            9      EACH        $300.00    $2,700.00     $400,00    $3,600.00   $325.00    $2,925.00    $350.00     $3,150.00       $400.00        $3,600.00
 3   ADJUST WATER VALVE CASTING                        5      EACH        $250.00    $1,250.00     $350.00    $1,750.00   $325.00    $1,625.00    $290.00     $1,450.00       $250,00        $1,250.00
 4   AGGREGATE BASE COURSE 22A@AS NEEDED              75       TON         $15.00    $1,125.00      $20.00    $1,500.00    $18.00    $1,350.00     $45.00     $3,375.00        $15,00        $1,125.00
 5   BIT. LEVELING MIX 3C@ 165#/S.Y.                 115       TON         $56.55    $6,503.25      $56.51    $6,498.65    $56.51    $6,498.65     $50.00     $5,750.00        $48,00        $5,520.00
 6   BIT. TOP MIX 4C MOD. POYLMER ASPHALT @220       155       TON         $60.85    $9,431.75      $60.81    $9,425.55    $60.81    $9,425.55     $70.00   $10,850.00         $68.00       $10,540.00
 7   CATCH BAS!N CASTING E.J.#5105 OR EQUAL            2      EACH        $500.00    $1,000.00     $265.00      $530.00   $400,00      $800.00    $600.00     $1,200.00       $450.00          $900.00
 8   CATCH BAS!N CASTING E.J.#7045 OR EQUAL          10       EACH        $510.00    $5,100.00     $300.00    $3,000.00   $450.00    $4,500.00    $500.00     $5,000.00       $475.00        $4,750.00
 9   CATCH BASIN 2' I.D.                              3       EACH      $1,045.00    $3,135.00   $1,000.00    $3,000.00   $900,00    $2,700.00    $900.00     $2,700.00       $750.00        $2,250.00
10   CATCH BASIN FLAT TOP                              6      EACH      $1,260.00    $7,560.00   $1,250.00    $7,500.00 $1,400.00    $8,400.00  $1,200.00     $7,200.00     $1,200.00        $7,200.00
11   CEMENT                                            6       TON        $150.00      $900.00       $1.00        $6.00     $1.00        $6.00    $200.00     $1,200.00         $1.00            $6.00
12   CONG. BASE COURSE 8"                             56     SQ.YD.        $41.50    $2,324.00      $28.00    $1,568.00    $28,00    $1,568.00     $30.00     $1,680.00        $29.00        $1,624.00
13   CONG. CURB & GUTTER F-4 MOD.                    160     LIN. FT.      $12.90    $2,064.00       $9.00    $1,440.00     $8.00    $1,280.00     $13.00     $2,080.00        $10.00        $1,600.00
14   CONG. CURB 6"x 14"                              20      LIN. FT.      $16.00      $320.00      $12.00      $240.00    $12.00      $240.00     $13.00       $260.00        $14.00          $280.00
15   CONG. DRIVE APPROACH 6" STD.                    144     SQ.YD.        $26.50    $3,816.00      $32.00    $4,608.00    $24.00    $3,456.00     $25.00     $3,600.00        $28.50        $4,104.00
16   CONG. DRIVE APPROACH 8" STD.                   238      SQ.YD.        $34.50    $8,211.00      $37.00    $8,806.00    $28.00    $6,664.00     $29.00     $6,902.00        $32.50        $7,735.00
17   CONG. PAVEMENT 7" W / 6" INTEGRAL CURB NO      8555     SQ.YD.        $22.80  $195,054.00      $24.75  $211,736.25    $23.06  $197,278.30     $23.80  $203,609.00         $36.50      $312,257.50
18   CONG. SIDEWALK 4"                               655     SO.FT.         $2.15    $1,408.25       $2.25    $1,473.75     $2.00    $1,310.00      $3.00     $1,965.00         $2.50        $1,637.50
19   CONG. SIDEWALK 8"                              200      SQ.FT.         $3.80      $760.00       $3.00      $600.00     $2.50      $500.00      $4.00       $800.00         $3.00          $600,00
20   CORP. STOP 1" MUELLER #15000 OR EQUAL             1      EACH        $275.00      $275.00     $250.00      $250.00   $275.00      $275.00    $400.00       $400.00      $500.00           $500.00
21   EXCAVATION                                     1047     CU.YD.        $18.25   $19,107.75       $8.00    $8,376.00     $7.00    $7,329.00      $7.00     $7,329.00         $6.00        $6,282.00
22   MANHOLE CASTING E.J.#1000 OR EQUAL                9      EACH        $500.00    $4,500.00     $200.00    $1,800.00   $375.00    $3,375.00    $450.00     $4,050.00      $550.00         $4,950.00
23   MANHOLE STD. 4' I.D. O' TO 10' DEEP               1      EACH      $1,450.00    $1,450.00   $1,400.00    $1,400.00 $1,800.00    $1,800.00  $1,900.00     $1,900.00     $1,450.00        $1,450.00
24   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 4" WHITE             65     LIN. FT.       $1.20       $78.00       $1.10       $71,50     $1.10       $71.50      $2.00       $130.00         $1.10           $71.50
25   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 4"YELLOW           1725     LIN. FT.       $1.20    $2,070.00       $1.10    $1,897.50     $1.10    $1,897.50      $1.50     $2,587.50         $1.10        $1,897.50
26   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 6" CROSSW           100     LIN. FT.       $2.45      $245.00       $2.25      $225.00     $2.25      $225.00      $2.40       $240.00         $2.25          $225.00
27   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 12" STOP B           18     LIN. FT.       $5.00       $90.00       $4.50       $81.00     $4.50       $81 .00     $5.00        $90.00         $4.50           $81.00
28   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE SYMBOL LT.            1      EACH         $85.00       $85.00      $75.00       $75.00    $75.00       $75.00     $90.00        $90.00        $75.00           $75.00
29   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE SYMBOL 0              1      EACH         $95.00       $95.00      $85.00       $85.00    $85.00       $85.00    $105.00       $105.00        $85.00           $85,00
30   PAVEMENT PREPARATORY WORK                       3.7       STA.       $550.00    $2,035.00     $550.00    $2,035.00   $550.00    $2,035.00    $900.00     $3,330.00       $800.00        $2,960.00
31   RECONSTRUCTING STRUCTURES M.H.& C.B.             10      V.FT.       $325.00    $3,250.00     $166.41    $1,664.10   $600.00    $6,000.00    $325.00     $3,250.00       $275.00        $2,750.00
32   REMOVING BIT. SURFACE 2.5" TO 3.5" BY COLD M    3.7       STA.     $1,065.00    $3,940.50   $1,065.00    $3,940.50 $1,065.00    $3,940.50  $1,300.00     $4,810.00     $1,100.00        $4,070.00
33   REMOVING CATCH BASIN                              3      EACH        $400,00    $1,200.00     $141.24      $423.72   $225.00      $675,00    $500.00     $1,500.00       $200.00          $600.00
34   REMOVING CONC. DRIVE APPROACH                   239     SQ.YD.         $8.00    $1,912.00       $3.24      $774.36     $9.00    $2,151.00      $8.00     $1,912.00         $4.50        $1,075.50
35   REMOVING CONC. SIDEWALK                          90     SQ.FT.         $1.25      $112.50       $0.45       $40,50     $6,00      $540.00      $2.00       $180.00         $2.00          $180.00
36   REMOVING MANHOLES                                 1      EACH        $500.00      $500.00     $150.00      $150.00   $225.00      $225.00    $800.00       $800.00       $300.00          $300.00
37   REMOVING PAVEMENT                              7130     SQ.YD.         $5.90   $42,067.00       $4.50   $32,085.00     $7.00   $49,910.00      $3.50   $24,955.00          $5.00       $35,650.00
38   REMOVING TREES 37" OR LARGER                      1      EACH      $1,375.00    $1,375.00     $700.00      $700,00   $650,00      $650.00  $3,000.00     $3,000.00     $1,000.00        $1,000.00
39   STORM SEWER 10" O.C.I. CL. 52                    73     LIN.FT.       $30.00    $2,190.00      $33.00    $2,409.00    $45.00    $3,285.00     $31.00     $2,263.00        $34.00        $2,482.00
40   STORM SEWER 15" CONG. C-76 CL. V                488     LIN.FT.       $29.00   $14,152.00      $23.00   $11,224.00    $28.00   $13,664.00     $34.00   $16,592.00         $25.00       $12,200.00
41   TERRACE GRADING                                2521     LIN. FT.       $8.15   $20,546.15       $5.00   $12,605.00     $5.00   $12,605.00     $11.00   $27,731.00          $9.75       $24,579.75
42   TRAFFIC CONTROL                                   1      LUMP      $9,975.00    $9,975.00 $18,400.00    $18,400.00 $3,750.00    $3,750.00  $5,000.00     $5,000.00     $4,000.00        $4,000.00
43   WATER METER PIT COMPLETE                          1      EACH        $745.00      $745.00     $509,00      $509.00   $725.00      $725,00    $400.00       $400.00       $650.00          $650.00
44   WATER SERVICE 1" TYPE "K'' COPPER                60     LIN. FT.      $15.00      $900.00      $16.00      $960,00    $12.50      $750.00     $14.00       $840.00         $4.00          $240.00
45   WATER VALVE BOXW / COVER COMPLETE                 5      EACH        $325.00    $1,625.00      $86,00      $430.00   $500.00    $2,500.00    $450.00     $2,250.00       $500.00        $2,500.00
46   STORM SEWER 12" CONG. C-76 CL. V                 56     LIN. FT.      $25.00    $1,400.00      $25.00    $1,400.00    $45.00    $2,520.00     $35.00     $1,960.00        $26.00        $1,456.00
                                          NIMS & IRWIN CONC. TOTAL                $389,783.15             .$372.493.38             $372,966.00              $381,865.50                    $480,489.25
                                                            H-1564 NIMS & IRWIN, WOOD ST. TO GETTY ST.
                                                            BID TABULATION - CONCRETE 05/20/03 -PAGE 2
                                                    CONTRACTOR ORTH RIVER EXCAVATIN                DAN HOE EXCAVATING         MILBOCKER & SONS          NAGEL CONSTRUCTION
                                                     ST ADDRESS   9918 N. RIVER RD.                 13664 ROCKY'S RD.            1256 29TH ST.                PO BOX 10
                                                          CITY/ST/ZIP    NEWAYGO, Ml 49337      HOLLAND, Ml 49424      ALLEGAN, Ml 49010     MOLINE, Ml 49335-0010
                 DESCRIPTION                      QUANT!T      UNIT    UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE
1    ADJUST CATCH BASIN CASTING                      4         EACH       $225.00      $900.00    $325.00   $1,300.00    $385.00   $1,540.00   $315.00     $1,260.00
2    ADJUST MANHOLE CASTING                          9         EACH       $225.00    $2,025.00    $350.00   $3,150.00    $385.00   $3,465.00   $315.00     $2,835.00
3    ADJUST WATER VALVE CASTING                       5        EACH       $200.00    $1,000.00    $125.00     $625.00    $130.00     $650.00   $230.00     $1,150.00
4    AGGREGATE BASE COURSE 22A @AS NEEDED            75         TON         $16.00   $1,200.00     $15.00   $1,125.00     $14.70   $1,102,50      $4,50      $337.50
5    BIT. LEVELING MIX 3C@ 165#/S.Y.                115         TON         $75.00   $8,625.00     $50.00   $5,750.00     $56.51   $6,498.65     $60.00    $6,900.00
6    BIT, TOP MIX 4C MOD, POYLMER ASPHALT@ 220      155         TON         $85.00  $13,175.00     $70.00  $10,850.00     $60.81   $9,425.55     $70.00   $10,850.00
7    CATCH BASIN CASTING E.J.#5105 OR EQUAL          2         EACH       $500.00    $1,000.00    $500.00   $1,000.00    $552.00   $1,104.00   $510.00     $1,020.00
8    CATCH BASIN CASTING E.J.#7045 OR EQUAL          10        EACH       $525.00    $5,250.00    $500.00   $5,000.00    $577.00   $5,770.00   $560.00     $5,600.00
9    CATCH BASIN 2' !.D.                             3         EACH       $800.00    $2,400.00  $1,100.00   $3,300.00    $845.00   $2,535.00   $880.00     $2,640.00
10   CATCH BASIN FLAT TOP                            6         EACH       $350.00    $2,100.00  $1,100.00   $6,600.00  $1,347.00   $8,082.00   $330.00     $1,980.00
11   CEMENT                                          6          TON       $160.00      $960.00    $100.00     $600.00      $1.00       $6.00   $150.00       $900.00
12   CONG. BASE COURSE 8"                           56        SQ.YD.        $25.50   $1,428.00     $32.00   $1,792.00     $28.00   $1,568.00     $37.00    $2,072.00
13   CONG.   CURB & GUTTER F-4 MOD.                 160       LIN, FT.      $18.00   $2,880.00     $10.50   $1,680.00      $8.00   $1,280.00     $10.00    $1,600.00
14   CONG.   CURB 6"x 14"                            20       LIN, FT.      $18.00     $360.00     $20.00     $400.00     $12.00     $240.00     $15.00      $300.00
15   CONC.   DRIVE APPROACH 6" STD.                 144       SQ.YD.        $25.50   $3,672.00     $29.00   $4,176.00     $24.00   $3,456.00     $33.00    $4,752.00
16   CONG.   DRIVE APPROACH 8" STD.                238        SQ.YD.        $27,50   $6,545.00     $34.00   $8,092.00     $28.00   $6,664.00     $37.00    $8,806.00
17   CONG. PAVEMENT T' W / 6" INTEGRAL CURB NO     8555       SQ.YD.       $29.25    $250,233.75      $26.00    $222,430.00     $23.06    $197,278.30      $34.00    $290,870.00
18   CONC. SIDEWALK 4"                              655       SQ.FT.        $3.50      $2,292.50       $3.00      $1,965.00      $2.00      $1,310.00       $3.50      $2,292.50
19   CONG. SIDEWALK 8"                             200        SQ.FT.        $5.00      $1,000.00       $6.00      $1,200.00      $2.50        $500.00       $5.50      $1,100.00
20   CORP. STOP 1" MUELLER #15000 OR EQUAL           1        EACH        $450.00        $450.00     $400.00        $400,00    $245.00        $245.00     $205,00        $205,00
21 EXCAVATION                                       1047      CU.YD,        $6.00      $6,282,00       $15.00    $15,705.00      $14.30    $14,972.10       $4.35      $4,554.45
22 MANHOLE CASTING E.J.#1000 OR EQUAL                9         EACH       $480.00      $4,320.00      $300.00     $2,700.00     $550,00     $4,950.00      $440.00     $3,960.00
23 MANHOLE STD. 4' 1.0. O' TO 10' DEEP                1        EACH      $1,200.00     $1,200.00    $1,300.00     $1,300.00   $1,280.00     $1,280.00    $1,700.00     $1,700.00
24 PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 4" WHITE              65       LIN. FT.       $1.25        $81.25        $1.00        $65.00      $1.10         $71.50        $1.20        $78.00
25 PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 4" YELLOW            1725      LIN. FT.       $1.25     $2,156.25        $1.00     $1,725.00      $1.10      $1,897.50        $1.20     $2,070.00
26 PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 6" CROSSW             100      LIN. FT.       $2.50       $250.00        $5.00       $500,00       $2.25       $225.00        $2.50       $250.00
27 PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 12" STOP B            18       LIN. FT.       $5.00        $90.00        $9.00      $162.00        $4.50        $81.00        $5.00        $90.00
28 PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE SYMBOL LT.             1        EACH        $100.00       $100.00     $100.00       $100.00       $75.00        $75.00      $100.00       $100.00
29 PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE SYMBOL 0               1       EACH         $115.00       $115.00     $100.00        $100.00      $85.00        $85.00      $100.00       $100.00
30 PAVEMENT PREPARATORY WORK                         3.7      STA          $900.00     $3,330.00      $900.00     $3,330.00     $960.00     $3,552.00    $1,000.00     $3,700.00
31 RECONSTRUCTING STRUCTURES M.H.& C.B.              10       V.FT.        $200.00     $2,000.00      $350.00     $3,500.00     $247.00     $2,470.00      $250.00     $2,500.00
32 REMOVING BIT. SURFACE 2.5" TO 3.5" BY COLD M     3.7       STA.       $1,200.00     $4,440.00    $1,200.00     $4,440.00   $1,500.00     $5,550.00    $1,000.00     $3,700.00
33 REMOVING CATCH BASIN                              3         EACH       $250.00       $750.00       $200.00      $600.00      $330,00       $990.00      $100.00       $300.00
34 REMOVING CONG. DRIVE APPROACH                    239       SQ.YD.        $8.00      $1,912.00        $4.00      $956.00        $5.40     $1,290.60        $3.12       $745.68
35 REMOVING CONG. SIDEWALK                           90       SQ.FT.        $1.00        $90.00         $1.00        $90.00       $1.23       $110.70        $1.70       $153,00
36 REMOVING MANHOLES                                 1        EACH        $500.00       $500.00      $250.00        $250.00     $330.00       $330.00      $170.00       $170.00
37 REMOVING PAVEMENT                                7130      SQ.YD.         $6.00    $42,780.00        $4.50    $32,085.00       $3.50    $24,955.00        $5.15    $36,719.50
38 REMOVING TREES 37" OR LARGER                       1       EACH       $1,000.00     $1,000.00     $750.00       $750.00    $1,000.00     $1,000.00      $600.00        $600.00
39 STORM SEWER 10" D.C.l. CL. 52                     73       LIN. FT.     $25.00      $1,825.00      $30.00      $2,190.00      $37.00     $2,701.00       $34.00     $2,482.00
40 STORM SEWER 15" CONG. C-76 CL. V                 488       LIN. FT.     $27.00     $13,176.00       $30.00    $14,640.00      $28.00    $13,664.00       $28.50    $13,908.00
41 TERRACE GRADING                                  2521      LIN. FT.      $12.00    $30,252.00        $7.00    $17,647.00      $18.80    $47,394.80        $3.70     $9,327.70
42 TRAFFIC CONTROL                                    1        LUMP      $5,000.00     $5,000.00    $5,000.00     $5,000.00   $5,400.00     $5,400.00    $4,000.00     $4,000.00
43 WATER METER PIT COMPLETE                           1        EACH        $500.00       $500.00      $850.00       $850.00     $800.00      $800.00       $300.00       $300.00
44 WATER SERVICE 1" TYPE "K'' COPPER            60    LIN. FT.             $15.00       $900.00       $20.00      $1,200.00     $16.50       $990.00        $1.40         $84.00
45 WATER VALVE BOX W / COVER COMPLETE            5     EACH               $400.00      $2,000.00     $150.00        $750.00    $410.00      $2,050.00      $90.00        $450.00
46 STORM SEWER 12" CONG. C~76 CL. V             56    LIN. FT.             $25.00      $1,400.00      $30.00      $1,680.00     $27.00      $1,512.00      $27.00      $1,512.00
                                    NIMS & IRWIN CONC. TOTAL                         $433,945.75                $393,750.00               $391,117.20                $441,024.33
                                                                                            H-1564 NIMS & IRWIN, WOOD ST, TO GETTY ST.
                                                                                             BID TABULATION -ASPHALT 05120/03 - PAGE 1
                                                     CONTRACTOR      JACKSON-MERKEY      KAMMINGA & ROODVOET PRINCE BRJDGE & MARIN                       FELCO CONTRACTORS           WADEL STABILIZATION
                                                      ST ADDRESS    555 E. WESTERN AVE.  3435 BROADMOOR AVES         POBOX510                              874 PULASKI AVE.             2500 OCEANA DR
                                                       CITY/ST/ZIP USKEGON, Ml 49442-103 GRANO RAPIDS, Ml 49512 GRAND HAVEN, Ml 49417                    MUSKEGON, Ml 49441           HART, Ml 49420-8116
                 DESCRIPTION                        QUANTITY UNIT         UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE              UNIT PRICE   TOTAL PRICE
1    ADJUST CATCH BASIN CASTING                         4      EACH          $300.00    $1,200.00    $300.00   $1,200.00   $325.00    $1,300.00        350   $1,400.00                  $300.00      $1,200.00
2    ADJUST MANHOLE CASTING                            9       EACH          $400.00    $3,600.00    $400.00   $3,600.00   $325.00    $2,925.00   $350.00    $3,150.00                 $400.00       $3,600.00
3    ADJUST WATER VALVE CASTING                        5       EACH          $300.00    $1,500.00    $350.00   $1,750.00   $325.00    $1,625.00   $290.00    $1,450.00                 $250.00       $1,250.00
4    AGGREGATE BASE COURSE 22A@AS NEEDED               75      TON             $15.00   $1,125.00     $20.00   $1,500.00     $18.00   $1,350.00     $45.00   $3,375.00                  $15.00       $1,125.00
5    AGGREGATE BASE COURSE 22A @8" C.I.P.             7495     SQ.YD.           $5.90  $44,220.50      $5.50  $41,222.50      $6.75  $50,591.25      $6.00  $44,970.00                   $5.50      $41,222.50
6    BIT. LEVELING M!X 3C@ 165#/S.Y.                  773       TON            $34.05  $26,320.65     $34.01  $26,289.73     $34.01  $26,289.73     $36.00  $27,828.00                  $34.01      $26,289.73
7    BIT. TOP MIX 4C MOD. POYLMER ASPHALT @ 220       1065      TON           $39.50    $42,067.50     $39.50     $42,067.50     $39.50     $42,067.50      $41.00    $43,665.00        $39.50      $42,067.50
8    CATCH BASIN CASTING E.J.#5105 OR EQUAL             2      EACH          $500.00     $1,000.00    $265.00        $530.00    $400.00       $800.00     $600.00      $1,200.00       $450.00         $900.00
9  CATCH BASIN CASTING E.J.#7045 OR EQUAL              10      EACH         $510.00      $5,100.00    $300,00      $3,000.00    $450.00      $4,500.00    $500.00      $5,000.00       $475.00       $4,750.00
10 CATCH BASIN 2' I.D.                                  3      EACH        $1,045.00     $3,135.00   $1,000.00     $3,000.00    $900.00      $2,700.00    $900.00      $2,700.00       $750.00       $2,250.00
11   CATCH BASIN FLAT TOP                               6      EACH        $1.260.00     $7,560.00   $1,250.00     $7,500.00   $1,400.00     $8,400.00   $1,200.00     $7,200.00     $1,200.00       $7,200.00
12   CEMENT                                             6       TON          $150.00      $900.00     $100.00        $600.00    $150.00       $900.00     $200.00      $1,200.00       $150.00         $900.00
13   CONC. BASE COURSE 8"                              56      SQ.YD.         $24.75     $1,386.00     $32.00      $1,792.00     $24.75      $1,386.00      $30.00     $1,680.00        $26.00       $1,456.00
14   CONC. CURB & GUTTER F-4 MOD.                     4910     LIN. FT.        $7.75    $38,052.50     $11.00     $54,010.00      $7.75     $38,052.50       $8.50    $41,735.00         $9.75      $47,872.50
15   CONG. CURB 6"x 14"                                20      LIN. FT.       $10.00      $200.00      $20.00        $400.00     $10.00       $200.00       $13.00       $260.00        $12.00         $240.00
16   CONG. DRIVE APPROACH 6" STD.                     144      SQ.YD.         $24.30     $3,499.20     $32.00      $4,608.00     $24.30      $3,499.20     $26.00      $3,744.00        $28.80       $4,147.20
17   CONG. DRIVE APPROACH 8" STD.                     238      SQ.YD.         $26.10     $6,211.80     $37.00      $8,806.00     $26.10      $6,211.80     $30.00      $7,140.00        $30.60       $7,282.80
18   CONG. SIDEWALK 4"                                655      SQ.FT.          $2.50     $1,637.50       $2.25     $1,473.75       $2.50     $1,637.50       $3.00     $1,965.00         $3.00       $1,965.00
19   CONG. SIDEWALK 8"                                200      SQ.FT.          $2.90      $580.00        $3.91       $782.00       $2.90      $580.00        $5.00     $1,000.00         $3.40         $680.00
20   CORP. STOP 1" MUELLER #15000 OR EQUAL              1      EACH          $275.00      $275.00     $250.00        $250.00    $275.00       $275.00     $400.00        $400.00       $500.00         $500.00
21   EXCAVATION                                       1972     CU.YD.         $11.80    $23,269.60       $8,00    $15,776.00      $7.00     $13,804.00       $6.00    $11,832.00         $5.00       $9,860.00
22   MANHOLE CASTING E.J.#1000 OR EQUAL                9       EACH         $500.00      $4,500.00    $200.00      $1,800.00    $375.00      $3,375.00    $450.00      $4,050.00       $550.00       $4,950.00
23   MANHOLE STD. 4' 1.0. O' TO 10' DEEP                1      EACH        $1,450.00     $1,450.00   $1,400.00     $1,400.00   $1,800.00     $1,800.00   $1,900.00     $1,900.00     $1,450.00       $1,450.00
24   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 4" WHITE              65      LIN. FT.        $1.20        $78.00       $1.10        $71.50       $1.10        $71.50       $2.00       $130.00         $1.10          $71.50
25   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 4" YELLOW            1725     LIN. FT.        $1.20     $2,070.00       $1.10     $1,897.50      $1.10      $1,897.50       $1,50     $2,587.50         $1.10       $1,897.50
26   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 6" CROSSW            100      LIN. FT.        $2.45      $245.00        $2.25       $225.00      $2.25       $225.00        $2.40       $240.00         $2.25         $225.00
27   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 12" STOP B            18      LIN. FT.        $5.00        $90.00      $4.50         $81.00       $4.50        $81.00       $5.00        $90.00         $4.50           $81.00
28   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE SYMBOL LT.             1      EACH           $85.00        $85.00     $75.00         $75.00     $75.00         $75.00     $90.00         $90.00        $75.00           $75.00
29   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE SYMBOL 0               1      EACH           $95.00        $95.00     $85,00         $85.00     $85.00        $85.00     $105.00        $105.00        $85,00           $85.00
30   PAVEMENT PREPARATORY WORK                        3.7       STA.         $800.00     $2,960.00    $800.00      $2,960.00    $800,00      $2,960.00    $850,00      $3,145.00       $800.00       $2,960.00
31   RECONSTRUCTING STRUCTURES M.H.& C.B.              10       V.FT.        $325.00     $3,250.00    $175,00      $1,750.00    $600.00      $6,000.00    $325.00      $3,250.00       $275.00       $2,750.00
32   REMOVING B!T. SURFACE 2.5" TO 3.5" BY COLD M     3.7       STA.       $1.100.00     $4,070.00   $1,100.00     $4,070.00   $1,100.00     $4,070.00   $1,200.00     $4,440.00     $1,100.00       $4,070.00
33   REMOVING CATCH BAS!N                              3       EACH          $400.00     $1,200.00    $150.00        $450.00    $225.00       $675.00     $500.00      $1,500.00       $200.00         $600.00
34   REMOVING CONG. DRIVE APPROACH                    239      SQ.YD.          $8.00     $1,912.00       $4.00       $956.00      $9.00      $2,151.00      $8.00      $1,912.00         $4.50       $1,075.50
35   REMOVING CONC. SIDEWALK                           90      SQ.FT.          $1.25      $112.50        $0.45       $40.50       $6.00       $540.00       $2.00        $180.00         $2.00         $180.00
36   REMOVING MANHOLES                                  1       EACH         $500.00      $500.00     $150.00       $150.00     $225.00       $225.00     $800.00       $800.00        $300.00         $300.00
37   REMOVING PAVEMENT                                7130     SQ.YD.          $4.60    $32,798.00       $4.50    $32,085.00      $5.75     $40,997.50       $3.50    $24,955.00         $5.00      $35,650.00
38   REMOVING TREES 37" OR LARGER                       1       EACH       $1,375.00     $1,375.00    $700.00       $700,00     $650.00       $650.00    $2,000.00     $2,000.00     $1,000.00       $1,000.00
39   STORM SEWER 10" D.C.!. CL. 52                     73      LIN. FT.       $30.00     $2,190.00     $33.00      $2,409.00     $45.00      $3,285.00     $31.00      $2,263.00        $34.00       $2,482.00
40   STORM SEWER 15" CONG. C-76 CL. V                 488      LIN. FT.       $29.00    $14,152.00     $23.00     $11,224.00     $28.00     $13,664.00     $33.00     $16,104.00        $25.00      $12,200.00
41   TERRACE GRADING                                  2521     LIN. FT.        $8.15    $20,546.15       $5.00    $12,605.00      $5.00     $12,605.00     $11.00     $27,731.00         $9.75      $24,579.75
42   TRAFFIC CONTROL                                    1      LUMP        $4,675.00     $4,675.00   $9,000.00     $9,000.00   $3,750.00     $3,750.00   $4,000.00     $4,000.00     $4,000.00       $4,000.00
43   WATER METER PIT COMPLETE                           1      EACH          $745.00      $745.00     $509.00       $509.00     $725.00       $725.00     $400.00       $400.00        $650.00         $650.00
44   WATER SERVICE 1~ TYPE "K" COPPER                  60      LIN. FT.       $15.00      $900.00      $16.00       $960.00      $12.50       $750,00      $14.00       $840.00          $4.00         $240.00
45   WATER VALVE BOX W / COVER COMPLETE                5       EACH          $325.00     $1,625.00     $86.00       $430.00     $500.00      $2,500.00    $450.00      $2,250.00       $500.00       $2,500.00
46   STORM SEWER 12" CONC. C-76 CL. V                  56      LIN. FT.       $25.00     $1,400.00     $25.00      $1,400.00     $45.00      $2,520.00     $33.00      $1,848.00        $26,00       $1,456.00
                                                    NIMS & IRWIN TOTAL                 $315,863.90               $307,490.98               $314,771.98               $319,704.50                   $312,286.48
                                                                              H-1564 NIMS & IRWIN, WOOD ST. TO GETTY ST.
                                                                               BID TABULATION -ASPHALT 05120/03 -PAGE 2
                                                     CONTRACTOR            DAN HOE EXCAVATING        MlLBOCKER & SONS          HALLACK CONTRACTING        NAGEL CONSTRUCTION         HEYBOER EXCAVATING
                                                      ST ADDRESS            13664 ROCKY'S RD.         1256 29TH ST.        4223 W. POLK RD.            PO BOX 10                         17340 HAYES ST
                                                       CITY /ST/ZIP         HOLLAND, Ml 49424      ALLEGAN, Ml 4901 O        HART, Ml 49420       MOLINE, Ml 49335--0010             GRAND HAVEN, Ml 49417
                    DESCRIPTION                     QUANTITY UNIT         UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE               UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE
1 ADJUST CATCH BASIN CASTING                            4      EACH          $325.00    $1,300.00   $385.00     $1,540.00  $500.00      $2,000.00   $315.00     $1,260.00              $350,00       $1,400.00
2    ADJUST MANHOLE CASTING                             9      EACH          $350.00    $3,150.00   $385.00     $3,465.00  $500.00      $4,500.00   $315.00     $2,835.00              $350.00       $3,150.00
 3   ADJUST WATER VALVE CASTING                         5      EACH          $125.00      $625.00   $130.00       $650,00  $200,00      $1,000.00   $230.00     $1,150.00              $200,00       $1,000.00
 4   AGGREGATE BASE COURSE 22A @AS NEEDED              75      TON            $10.00      $750.00      $14.70      $1,102.50       $20.00     $1,500.00      $10.00       $750.00       $10.00            $750.00
 5   AGGREGATE BASE COURSE 22A @8" C.I.P.            7495      SQ.YD.          $5.50    $41,222.50      $5.30     $39,723.50        $5.50    $41,222.50       $7.00    $52,465.00         $5.00     $37,475.00
 6   BIT. LEVELING MIX 3C@ 165#/S.Y.                  773       TON           $37.00    $28,601.00     $34.01     $26,289.73       $36.00    $27,828.00      $36.00    $27,828.00       $34.01      $26,289.73
 7   BIT. TOP MIX4C MOD. POYLMER ASPHALT @220         1065      TON           $41.00    $43,665.00     $39.50     $42,067.50       $40.00    $42,600.00      $40.00    $42,600.00       $39.50      $42,067.50
 8   CATCH BASIN CASTING E.J.#5105 OR EQUAL            2       EACH          $500.00     $1,000.00    $552.00      $1,104.00     $675.00      $1,350.00     $510.00     $1,020.00      $500.00       $1,000.00
 9   CATCH BASIN CASTING E.J.#7045 OR EQUAL            10      EACH          $500.00     $5,000.00    $577.00      $5,770.00     $750.00      $7,500.00     $560.00     $5,600.00      $465.00       $4,650.00
10   CATCH BASIN 2' 1.D.                               3       EACH        $1,100.00     $3,300.00     $845.00     $2,535.00    $1,000.00     $3,000.00     $880.00     $2,640.00     $1,050.00      $3,150.00
11   CATCH BASIN FLAT TOP                              6       EACH        $1,100.00     $6,600.00   $1,347.00     $8,082.00      $900.00     $5,400.00     $330.00     $1,980.00     $1,500.00      $9,000.00
12   CEMENT                                            6        TON          $150.00      $900.00     $140.00       $840.00      $250.00      $1,500.00     $150.00       $900.00       $92.00        $552.00
13   CONG. BASE COURSE 8"                              56      SQ.YD.         $28.00     $1,568.00     $31.00      $1,736.00      $44.00      $2,464.00      $32.00     $1,792.00       $32.00       $1,792.00
14   CONC. CURB & GUTTER F-4 MOD.                    4910     LIN. FT.         $9.00    $44,190.00      $6.80     $33,388.00       $11.00    $54,010.00       $9.00    $44,190.00         $7.10     $34,861.00
15   CONC. CURB 6"x 14"                                20     LIN. FT.        $15.00      $300.00      $15.00       $300.00        $13.00      $260.00       $12.00       $240.00       $15.00        $300.00
16   CONC. DRIVE APPROACH 6" STD.                     144      SQ.YD.         $30.00     $4,320.00     $23.00      $3,312.00       $32.00     $4,608.00      $30.00     $4,320.00       $24.00       $3,456.00
17   CONC. DRIVE APPROACH 8" STD.                     238      SQ.YD.         $32.00     $7,616.00     $31.00      $7,378.00       $36.00     $8,568.00      $34.00     $8,092.00       $32.00       $7,616.00
18   CONC. SIDEWALK 4"                                655      SQ.FT.          $3.25     $2,128.75      $3.00      $1,965.00        $3.00     $1,965.00       $3.50     $2,292.50        $3.25       $2,128.75
19   CONG. SIDEWALK 8"                                200      SQ.FT.          $5.00     $1,000.00      $5.00      $1,000.00        $3.50      $700.00        $5.50     $1,100.00         $5.00      $1,000.00
20   CORP. STOP 1" MUELLER #15000 OR EQUAL              1      EACH          $400.00      $400.00     $245.00       $245.00      $200.00       $200.00      $385.00      $385.00       $125.00        $125.00
21   EXCAVATION                                       1972     CU.YD.         $11.00    $21,692.00      $9.75     $19,227.00        $8.00    $15,776.00       $4.35     $8,578.20       $10.25      $20,213.00
22   MANHOLE CASTING E.J.#1000 OR EQUAL                9       EACH          $300.00     $2,700.00    $550,00      $4,950.00     $510.00      $4,590.00     $440,00     $3,960.00      $330,00       $2,970.00
23   MANHOLE STD. 4' I.D. O' TO 10' DEEP                1      EACH        $1,300.00     $1,300.00   $1,280.00     $1,280.00    $1,400.00     $1,400.00   $1,700.00     $1,700.00     $1,450.00      $1,450.00
24   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 4" WHITE              65     LIN. FT.         $1.00        $65.00      $1.10        $71.50         $1.20        $78.00       $1.20        $78.00         $1.10           $71.50
25   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 4" YELLOW            1725    LIN. FT.         $1.00     $1,725.00      $1.10      $1,897.50        $1.20     $2,070.00       $1.20     $2,070.00         $1.10      $1,897.50
26   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 6" CROSSW            100      LIN. FT.        $5.00      $500.00        $2.25      $225.00         $2.50      $250.00        $2.50      $250.00          $2.25       $225.00
27   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE 12" STOP B            18     LIN. FT.         $9.00      $162.00        $4.50       $81.00         $5.00        $90.00       $5.00       $90.00          $4.50           $81.00
28   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE SYMBOL LT.            1       EACH          $100.00      $100.00      $75.00        $75.00      $100.00       $100.00      $100.00      $100.00        $75.00            $75.00
29   PAVEMENT MARKING WATERBORNE SYMBOL 0              1       EACH          $100.00      $100.00      $85.00        $85.00      $100.00       $100.00      $100.00      $100,00        $85.00            $85.00
30   PAVEMENT PREPARATORY WORK                        3.7       STA.         $900.00     $3,330.00    $960.00      $3,552.00     $600.00      $2,220.00   $1,000.00     $3,700.00      $800.00       $2,960.00
31   RECONSTRUCTING STRUCTURES M.H.& C.B.              10       V.FT.        $350.00     $3,500.00    $247.00      $2,470.00     $500.00      $5,000.00     $250.00     $2,500.00      $100.00       $1,000.00
32   REMOVING BIT. SURFACE 2.5" TO 3.5" BY COLD M     3.7       STA.       $1,200.00     $4,440.00   $1,500.00     $5,550.00    $1,150.00     $4,255.00   $1,100.00     $4,070.00     $1,100.00      $4,070.00
33   REMOVING CATCH BASIN                              3        EACH         $200.00      $600.00     $330.00       $990.00      $800.00      $2,400.00     $100.00      $300.00       $450.00       $1,350.00
34   REMOVING CONC. DRIVE APPROACH                    239      SQ.YD.          $4.00      $956.00        $5.40     $1,290.60      $10.00      $2,390.00       $3.12      $745.68          $4.50      $1,075.50
35   REMOVING CONG. SIDEWALK                          90       SQ.FT.          $1.00        $90.00      $1.23       $110.70         $5.00      $450.00        $1.70      $153.00          $3.00       $270.00
36   REMOVING MANHOLES                                  1      EACH          $250.00      $250.00     $330.00       $330.00      $800.00       $800,00      $170.00      $170.00       $450.00        $450.00
37   REMOVING PAVEMENT                                7130     SQ.YD.          $4.00    $28,520.00       $3.50    $24,955.00        $5.00    $35,650.00       $5.15    $36,719.50         $2.90     $20,677.00
38   REMOVING TREES 37" OR LARGER                       1      EACH          $750.00      $750.00    $1,000.00     $1,000.00     $800.00       $800.00      $600.00      $600.00       $750.00        $750.00
39   STORM SEWER 10" D.C.I. CL. 52                     73      LIN. FT.       $30.00     $2,190.00     $37.90      $2,766.70      $30.00      $2,190.00      $34.00     $2,482.00       $30.50       $2,226.50
40   STORM SEWER 15" CONG. C-76 CL. V                 488      LIN.FT.        $30.00    $14,640.00     $27.00     $13,176.00      $27.00     $13,176.00      $28.50    $13,908.00       $23.50      $11,468.00
41   TERRACE GRADING                                  2521     LIN. FT.        $7.00    $17,647.00     $18.80     $47,394.80      $15.00     $37,815.00       $3.90     $9,831.90        $5.75      $14,495.75
42   TRAFFIC CONTROL                                    1       LUMP       $5,000.00     $5,000.00   $5,400.00     $5,400.00   $10,000.00    $10,000.00   $4,000.00     $4,000.00     $2,500.00      $2,500.00
43   WATER METER PIT COMPLETE                           1      EACH          $850.00      $850.00     $800.00       $800.00      $500.00       $500.00      $500,00      $500.00       $350.00        $350.00
44   WATER SERVICE 1" TYPE "K" COPPER                  60      LIN. FT.       $20.00     $1,200.00     $16.50       $990.00       $18.00      $1,080.00      $14.00      $840.00        $10.00        $600.00
45   WATER VALVE BOX W / COVER COMPLETE                5       EACH          $150.00      $750.00     $410.00      $2,050.00     $200.00      $1,000.00     $150.00      $750.00       $150.00        $750.00
46   STORM SEWER 12" CONC. C-76 CL. V                  56      LIN. FT.       $30.00     $1,680.00     $27.00      $1,512.00      $26.00      $1,456.00      $27.00     $1,512.00       $22.00       $1,232.00
                                                    NIMS & IRWIN TOTAL                 $312,373.25               $324,723.03                $357,811.50               $303,147.78                  $275,055.73
                               Life Cycle Anaylisis
      3.00%           Net Discount (5% Investment Return Less 2% Inflation)
                             concrete               asphalt

 Initial Investment           ($372,000.00)          ($275,000.00)
NPV OF Cash/lows              ($372,000.00)          ($395,051.52)     ($23,051.52)
         2003                         $0.00                  $0.00
         2004                         $0.00                  $0.00
         2005                         $0.00                  $0.00
         2006                         $0.00                  $0.00
         2007                         $0.00                  $0.00
         2008                         $0.00                  $0.00
         2009                         $0.00                  $0.00
         2010                         $0.00                  $0.00
         2011                        $0.00                   $0.00
         2012                        $0.00                   $0.00
         2013                        $0.00                   $0.00
         2014                        $0.00                  $0.00
         2015                        $0.00                  $0.00
         2016                        $0.00                  $0.00
         2017                        $0.00                  $0.00
         2018                        $0.00          ($100,000.00)
         2019                        $0.00                  $0.00
         2020                        $0.00                  $0.00
         2021                        $0.00                  $0.00
         2022                        $0.00                  $0.00
        2023                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2024                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2025                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2026                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2027                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2028                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2029                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2030                         $0.00          ($100,000.00)
        2031                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2032                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2033                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2034                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2035                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2036                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2037                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2038                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2039                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2040                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2041                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2042                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2043                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2044                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2045                         $0.00            ($50,000.00)
        2046                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2047                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2048                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2049                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2050                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2051                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2052                         $0.00                  $0.00
        2053                        $0.00                   $0.00
                                     AGENDA ITEM NO.   dCc3 - L\ c'l   c\~
                                CITY COMMISSION MEETING      6/10/03


 TO:            Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners

 FROM:          Bryon L. Mazade, City Manager

 DATE:          June 10, 2003

RE:             City Manager's Employment Agreement


SUMMARY OF REQUEST:

To approve changes to the City Manager's employment agreement.



FINANCIAL IMPACT:

$750 annually.



BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED:

None.



STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

Changes should be considered in two separate motions.

1)       Increase Auto Allowance by $750 per year.
2)       Increase Severance Pay from six months to seven months.



COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:




O:COMMON\DEPTMEN1\ADMINIAGNDA FRM
JMS • 0: (2003-04-MGR EMPLOYMENT AGMT)
                                             2003-49 (cl)
                                  EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT

                             CITY OF MUSKEGON - BRYON L. MAZADE
                                       Effective July I, 2003

         This employment agreement is made and entered into by and between the CITY OF

MUSKEGON ("CITY") and BRYON L. MAZADE ("MANAGER").


                                              Recitals

         A.       The CITY desires to employ the services of MANAGER as the City Manager of

the City of Muskegon as provided in the Charter of the City of Muskegon and desires to establish

conditions of employment, provide certain benefits and set working conditions for said

MANAGER.

         B.       MANAGER desires to maintain the employment as City Manager of the City of

Muskegon in accordance with the terms and provisions of the Agreement.

         C.       This Agreement supersedes all prior agreements.


                                             Agreement

         NOW THEREFORE, THE CITY AND MANAGER AGREE AS FOLLOWS:

         I.       EMPLOYMENT. CITY employs MANAGER as City Manager to perform the

functions and duties specified in the City Charter and ordinances and to perfo1m such other

legally permissible and proper duties and functions as the City Commission may, from time to

time, assign, and MANAGER accepts such employment.

                  MANAGER agrees to remain in the employ of the CITY until termination is

effected as hereinafter provided. MANAGER agrees to devote full time to his duties as City

Manager. MANAGER may undertake other incidental employment, subject to the right of the

City to require Manager to terminate other incidental employment.


C:\wlndows\TEMP\AZ1225.DOC
                                                  I
         2.       SALARY. Effective July 1, 2002, CITY agrees to pay MANAGER as

compensation for services rendered an annual salary of $105,256 per year. MANAGER shall be

entitled to cost of living adjustments approved by the City Commission for department heads on

the first of each year.

         3.       PENSION. It is understood by MANAGER that he will remain a member of the

City's General Employees Retirement System and remain eligible for all benefits thereunder.

         4.       FRINGE BENEFITS. In addition to the base salary and deferred compensation

established for MANAGER, CITY shall afford MANAGER the following:

                  (a)        Sick Leave. The existing sick leave bank shall be continued, and shall

continue to accrue at one (I) day per month, up to a maximum of 120 days.

                  (b)        Disability Insurance. During employment, a disability insurance policy

providing benefits for lost compensation until age sixty-five (65).

                  (c)        Holidays. Eleven (11) holidays per annum.

                  (d)        Vacation. Effective January 1, 2002, for each calendar year MANAGER

shall be entitled to five weeks vacation. Vacation time may be accumulated and carried over to

subsequent years, except that vacation time in excess of four weeks shall not be carried over and

shall be lost.

                  (e)        Life Insurance. A term life insurance policy during employment in the

amount provided for exempt employees.

                  (f)        Automobile Allowance. Effective July 1, 2003, an annual automobile

allowance of$6,750 for mileage shall be provided and payable in the 26 pay periods. In

addition, there shall be reimbursement for mileage at the standard City rate for a round trip of

100 miles or more on behalf of the CITY.



C:\windows\TEMP\AZ1225.DOC
                                                      2
                   (g)       Hospitalization Insurance. Coverage under the CITY'S hospitalization and

dental plan for MANAGER, MANAGER'S wife and children. MANAGER and MANAGER'S

dependents will, however, be subject to plan amendments adopted from time to time by the City

Commission.

                   (h)       Membership Dues and Expenses. Payment of annual ICMA membership

dues and payment of expenses to attend ICMA conferences within the State of Michigan.

Payment of the expenses to attend the annual ICMA conference. All other out of state

conferences must receive prior consent of City Commission.

                  (i)        Civic Organizations. CITY will pay or reimburse MANAGER for

membership dues and fees in one civic organizations, i.e. Rotary, Lions Club, etc., subject to the

City's ability to review and eliminate this benefit.

                  (j)        Miscellaneous. In addition to the fringe benefits set forth above, and to

the extent that this subparagraph does not duplicate or conflict with the above fringe benefits,

(which shall prevail), the MANAGER shall have the same fringe benefits as are available to the

highest level department heads employed by the CITY from time to time.

         5.       TERM. It is understood by both CITY and MANAGER that employment may be

terminated at the will of either party.

         6.       SEVERANCE PAY UPON TERMINATION BY CITY. If CITY terminates

MANAGER'S employment, or if termination occurs pursuant to section 8 ( except the last

paragraph thereof), MANAGER shall receive severance pay in an amount equal to seven (7)

months' salary, 50% of any unused sick leave pay and payment for unused vacation time earned

in that calendar year to the date of termination.




C:\windows\TEMP\AZ1225.DOC
                                                       3
          7.       TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT BY MANAGER. MANAGER may

terminate employment at any time after providing the CITY with a thirty (30) day notice.

          8.       SEVERANCE PAY UPON TERMINATION BY MANAGER. In the event the

CITY refuses, following written notice, to comply with any material provisions of this agreement

which financially benefit MANAGER, or MANAGER resigns following the simultaneous

suggestion, whether formal or informal, by a majority of the members of the City Commission

that he resign, then, in that event, the MANAGER may at his option be deemed to be terminated

at the date of such failure to comply or simultaneous suggestion. In such case, the MANAGER

shall be deemed to have been terminated by the CITY and entitled to the severance benefits set

forth above.

                  In the event the MANAGER terminates his employment for reasons other than

those stated in this paragraph, he shall receive one-half (1/2) of his unused sick leave bank and

all earned vacation pay for that calendar year, but no other severance pay or benefit, except as

required by law.

         9.       MERGER OF NEGOTIATIONS. This agreement constitutes the entire contract

of employment between CITY and MANAGER. No statement, promise, agreement, or

obligation that conflicts with the terms of this agreement shall modify, enlarge, or invalidate this

agreement or any provisions hereof.




C:\windows\TEMP\AZ1225.DOC
                                                 4
           IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the CITY and MANAGER have executed this agreement this

   10th day of         June   , 2003.




 WITNESSSES:




C:lwindows\TEMPIAZ1225.DOC
                                           5

Top of Page


Sign up for City of Muskegon Emails